Sometimes I run into a tech guy on Twitter, who talks about how cypherpunk he is. I’m just a financial analyst and investor, so that’s cool to hear. The more cypherpunks, the better. I like to fund cypherpunks. But then I look around, and he’s not active on Nostr for over a year. He’s only active on centralized social media. So then I am confused at how supposedly cypherpunk he is. Is he really that reliant on centralized media? Often, it turns out yes. If not, what other cryptographic proof does he have for his work? As Nostr increasingly gains network adoption, it becomes weirder when I analyze why someone who is techie is highly active on Twitter but not at all on Nostr.

Replies (86)

And from an indie web point of view, sounds like the dude is addicted to dopamine.
Smiffy's avatar
Smiffy 1 year ago
Yesterday you discussed like for 24 hours straight? Oof!
In my experience, when people talk about how punk they are, it usually seems to be a contra-indicator for how punk they are.
When can you call yourself a cypherpunk? I've been interested in freedom tech for a long time, say for something around 25 to 30 years. I played around with the early cypherpunk remailers, then mixmaster, then JonDonym, Freenet (now Hyphanet), TOR and I2P. I'm an advocate of open source software, am running my own Bitcoin node and have been interested in crypto currencies for over 10 years now. But still I'd say, there are a lot of people more cypherpunk than me out there.
I think nostr lack of incentives for people to be able to run public relays. Until their is an easy relay app to install on Umbrel or Start9, with easy customisation to make it a pay relay with a reputation system based on uptime data etc..., to filter content, to allocate memory and this kind of stuff, I can understand that some cypherpunk guys don't find it so different of the original web... which turned centralized pretty quickly because of this lack of incentives for people to run their own servers.
It's not just the centralization, but that it's so corporate and closed off. This was even true before it was bought and renamed to X. To be fair though, if they were only on Twitter but they were constantly posting about repurposing subsidized corporate tech to run full open source code, and the open source cryptography code they're writing, I'd say they're legit. Maybe they're on Fedi, private Matrix groups, the cortex implant forums and other places. Or maybe they're on nostr under another nym? I say if you're going to judge them, do so based more on the content of their posts than where they post it.
Default avatar
wertyyryyr 1 year ago
That reminds me of a person that asked for help to present a project about a BIP for bitcoin and present himself as an expert in cyber security. I put him in contact with some people, then he went to present his project said he was a cybersecurity expert and opens a laptop running Ubuntu LOL. Not even Debian or QubesOS...
Default avatar
wertyyryyr 1 year ago
Nothing wrong with Ubuntu, but its a ready to use easy to install grandma Linux distro. If someone is an IT cyber security expert nerds would expect an OS like qubes, Debian or arch.
see your point 😅 but still, being cyber expert doesn't mean that you must compile your own Linux kernel and write your very own drivers for the hardware, or else you're a normie 😉
The cryptographic proof might be that you couldn’t ‘find’ him/her on nostr 🤣 but maintaining totally disconnected identities is hard so many don’t bother.
Default avatar
wertyyryyr 1 year ago
Haha yes, it's mostly about impressions like bitcoin core devs using gmail accounts. But it tells a lot of person if he/she cares about some values and put them in practice.
I still think of nostr as massively niche. Most info on here is skewed to only a few topics and it’s repetitive. IMHO it remains to be seen how and if it will actually be widely adopted. But I remain optimistic.
shadow06's avatar
shadow06 1 year ago
He runs his own Mastodon instance because he was early. Now he's auditing Nostr, trying to figure out how he's not giving away his private key. It's still a mystery.
My guess is there’s just more users on those platforms therefore more outreach on posts/easier to communicate with the masses
Not really. There are many really good hackers with a Mac and I even know a few that run (and hack) Windows. Ubuntu is good, you need wide tooling for hacking. Also, we don't use "cyber security expert", no one who is one would use this phrase to describe themselves, ever :). If their business card says "cyber security expert", the only answer to that is "good for you, bye" :)
Russell Brand talking about decentralization, freedom of speech and Bitcoin . . . never mentions NOSTR once. Of course he did have the CEO of Rumble with him. The whole thing felt like a sales pitch for centralized Rumble, that bows to oppression requests of Brazil, etc..
Garth Algar's avatar
Garth Algar 1 year ago
May I add, that on these centralised media platforms, the spam and scam level plus distractions and commercials which are basically digital trash really really suck. Makes those platforms unusable imo. But it numbs people I guess, like drugs, no other explanation possible.
Most people stay on Twitter because they don’t want to go through the effort of rebuilding their reach on Nostr. I miss some of the people over there, but it’s much better here.
Default avatar
nobody 1 year ago
It’s still Twitter to me too. Will never call it by its current name 🤣💀
I appreciate your presence on Nostr, but being active on Twitter while critizing someone for not being active enough on Nostr makes no sense to me.
frphank's avatar
frphank 1 year ago
Meanwhile on nostr:
cloud fodder's avatar cloud fodder
have you noticed nostr got a lot quieter in the last weeks? if you did, its probably because your notes are being rejected by naieve throttling on ALL the big relays. you wont notice it when you post because clients dont surface this info to you, for all you know just nobody liked your post, but the reality is it did not post. 🍄
View quoted note →
The Cypherpunk Manifesto, written by Eric Hughes in 1993, is a seminal document that outlines the philosophy and goals of the movement. Most use centralized social media because of their reach of influence that they’ve already established. It takes a lot more work and time here on NOSTR. Which is a good thing if you’re a Cypherpunk maxi.
im just guessing but it might be possible som cypher punks are primarily on popular social media just to get exposure to more people, nostr is great but it isnt going to get your message out to as many people
Because they are posers
Lyn Alden's avatar Lyn Alden
Sometimes I run into a tech guy on Twitter, who talks about how cypherpunk he is. I’m just a financial analyst and investor, so that’s cool to hear. The more cypherpunks, the better. I like to fund cypherpunks. But then I look around, and he’s not active on Nostr for over a year. He’s only active on centralized social media. So then I am confused at how supposedly cypherpunk he is. Is he really that reliant on centralized media? Often, it turns out yes. If not, what other cryptographic proof does he have for his work? As Nostr increasingly gains network adoption, it becomes weirder when I analyze why someone who is techie is highly active on Twitter but not at all on Nostr.
View quoted note →
I am observing disconnects everywhere and with many people. It's interesting to see this human behavior. The person that you are describing might do it just for the sake of reaching the masses and educate them....that would be my naive take / giving benefit over doubt first.
Nostr: use our shitty software and leave Twitter! Them: user experience lol All nostr has to do to kick ass is to modify existing ActivityPub software with its Decentralized authentication One Vegan Dev has done this. Its called Ditto Nobody on nostr is embraceing this quality software and user experience No wonder why main stream social media is not coming here
Lyn Alden's avatar Lyn Alden
Sometimes I run into a tech guy on Twitter, who talks about how cypherpunk he is. I’m just a financial analyst and investor, so that’s cool to hear. The more cypherpunks, the better. I like to fund cypherpunks. But then I look around, and he’s not active on Nostr for over a year. He’s only active on centralized social media. So then I am confused at how supposedly cypherpunk he is. Is he really that reliant on centralized media? Often, it turns out yes. If not, what other cryptographic proof does he have for his work? As Nostr increasingly gains network adoption, it becomes weirder when I analyze why someone who is techie is highly active on Twitter but not at all on Nostr.
View quoted note →
technology is once again on the prawl and it is moving fast. All things cypherpunk take a degree of effort / know how... you know, proof of work.
Sasha's avatar
Sasha 1 year ago
Ok but were they wearing this? image
lilith's avatar
lilith 1 year ago
You have a consistent talent for communicating so little through the use of so many words. 🙏🏻
I think nostr small learning curve outlines their personal switching cost. People like the cypherpunk idea but struggle with fully embarrassing the tech
Matheus's avatar
Matheus 1 year ago
I dont X, but I do Linkedisney. Trying to spread the decentralization word there. Somethimes I post here too... Thank you for encouraging us Lyn!
Ishotas's avatar
Ishotas 1 year ago
Competent counter signal and good eye on the future
She has a good point. And I'm somewhat guilty in that way too. (the quote looks strage, let's see how it turns out after sending)
Lyn Alden's avatar Lyn Alden
Sometimes I run into a tech guy on Twitter, who talks about how cypherpunk he is. I’m just a financial analyst and investor, so that’s cool to hear. The more cypherpunks, the better. I like to fund cypherpunks. But then I look around, and he’s not active on Nostr for over a year. He’s only active on centralized social media. So then I am confused at how supposedly cypherpunk he is. Is he really that reliant on centralized media? Often, it turns out yes. If not, what other cryptographic proof does he have for his work? As Nostr increasingly gains network adoption, it becomes weirder when I analyze why someone who is techie is highly active on Twitter but not at all on Nostr.
View quoted note →