primal is unique among nostr apps in that it relies on a super relay: a caching server the caching server pulls notes and events from all known relays, the app then reads from the server rather than relays directly this setup provides both performance and privacy improvements users do not have to trust the caching server with message integrity because all events are signed but users do trust the caching server to show all events similar to traditional relays, anyone can run a caching server, users can easily change which server they use in settings the caching server is not used when broadcasting notes, broadcasts are sent directly to relays chosen by users the primal stack is open source, anyone can verify, run, or modify the code without permission nostr identities are transportable, all users can use any nostr app at will and are never locked in to primal

Replies (40)

If I run my own caching server, are you going to add it to your settings so I can't get censored by Primal?
Contra's avatar
Contra 1 year ago
Super relay is a clever middle layer. Offloads read pressure, improves UX, and stays true to Nostr’s trustless model. Open source and swappable? That’s how it should be.
Beautiful, except that, in my visual mind I cannot see this. Can we ask AI to make me a graphic so my 🐢 mind can comprehend better? Thanks for letting me know! 🫡
**The Tale of Two Towns: Cacheville and Nosteria** Once upon a time, in a land of communication and connection, there were two neighboring towns: Cacheville and Nosteria. Though close in distance, the way they shared information was completely different. In Cacheville, life was all about speed and efficiency. The town had a small post office with a clever system. Every time a resident asked for a letter from the big city, the post office would fetch it—but then, instead of throwing it away, they’d keep a copy in a little backroom. So, when someone else came asking for the same letter, the post office clerk would smile and say, “No need to wait—I’ve got a copy right here!” The people loved it. It saved time. It made everything feel fast. But there was one catch: if the letter ever changed in the big city, Cacheville wouldn't always know unless someone asked again. Still, for a town that liked things quick and simple, this worked perfectly. Now over in Nosteria, things were… different. They didn’t have a central post office. Instead, they had bulletin boards—lots of them—set up in town squares. If someone wanted to share a message, they’d walk up to a board and pin it themselves. Anyone walking by could stop and read it. Some people pinned their messages on just one board; others walked from square to square, pinning copies on many. There were no gatekeepers. Each bulletin board was run by a different person, and some accepted everything, while others had their own rules. But anyone could become a board host—and anyone could read the boards freely. It wasn’t as fast or tidy as Cacheville, but it was open, free, and no one could silence a message as long as someone, somewhere, was willing to pin it. And so, though Cacheville and Nosteria lived side by side, they served very different needs. One made things faster by remembering the past. The other made things freer by sharing the present with anyone who would listen. And in a world full of messages, both had their place. _ written by ChatGPT_
Default avatar
DELETED 1 year ago
People get confused by the mere presence of server and think centrization, not connecting that censorship can be performed directly on any #Nostr client itself. Full stack clients like #Primal are going to leave UI-only clients in the dust. nevent1qqsdxjenj5fp5rr0k28ntuyzwugeuw62a6h8hmy8zkn7wu7a5nhqmhcpr9mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuam9d3kx7unyv4ezumn9wspzqdtgwhlaw2dsdm45c8t6wzslw5qyt5r8waxjrs86llj272ledghgqvzqqqqqqy2guuqc
I was thinking about it, yeah based on the description in the note, I’m not sure what control Primal has over notes users can read, but users have the ability to post to whatever relays they want so in that direction can’t be censored.
The only big downside for me is that Primal does not have the ability to enter SOCKS 5 information into the app, so I can't use my Tor proxy, for example.
the axiom's avatar
the axiom 1 year ago
they can compute a feed on the server and promote content they want
primal cannot ban users the caching sever can block content from being seen but cannot block broadcasts users can easily switch caching server in settings menu or use a different nostr app
There are some notes from people saying the economics for running a caching server don't work out as a value-add on its own. > of course users could always use a different nostr app if they want to read from relays directly 🫡 the best part of the protocol.
there's a fundamental tension here. it's easier to build and benefit from centralized services than distributed apps. philosophically we want distributed, permissionless, censorship resistant things, but most people, most of the time, just pick the easy one. @jack often points this out. there isn't a simple answer, but maybe recognizing the asymmetry would reduce the emotional conflict. we're all on the same team
But there's none available options as the API is proprietary. Do suggest one that works here as an alternative.
that isn’t what he asked at all. Virtually zero people are ever going to manually run and specify their own caching server and you know it. “You can run our proprietary daemon that ONLY we use in the whole world and manually type it into your client, it’s incredibly simple to not be censored!” This is no different than libtards circa 2017 who were shouting “just run your own social media service!” The point is that there is clearly no effort on your part to ever delegate this central control over Nostr that you’ve claimed for yourself.
You say “primal cannot ban users” but then admit that it can block their content from being seen. This is, functionally, what has historically been referred to as a “shadowbox” and is not much different than being banned. If you cannot be displayed on the most-used Nostr client that has all the VC and advertising/promotion, then you can’t be competitive with any content producers on Nostr within the same vertical. You absolutely can, functionally, ban people. And it’s disingenuous to pretend otherwise.
Even if I assume 100% good faith from Odell and everyone at Primal, the fact is that most of the governments of the world have passed laws making demands of social media infrastructure providers, and force decisions from them on a regular basis. This doesn’t affect Nostr at the present moment because nobody is using it, but in the long-term as they have positioned themselves with the capability to censor, they will eventually be forced to do so on a regular basis if Nostr is not a failure. Even if Primal is not currently censoring people or manipulating eyeballs (which I have seen multiple attestations from people I respect who say otherwise), building a centralized service with the capability to censor in the first place should be met with deep contempt and mistrust.
Hofer99's avatar
Hofer99 5 months ago
Vaxx wasn't mandatory. You just lost your job and couldn't pay your mortage anymore. But vaxx was never mandatory.
That makes it seem like it would be a superset of available even major relays. That is not my experience. So what determines what is and is not included?
↑