Replies (75)
That's different. X silences people via their algorithms. Nostr giving users tools to mute assholes that don't understand what free speech means is the way forward.
You don't have to use those clients or those relays. That's the entire point of Nostr. I'd like to see a client that censors and bans and essentially acts like Twitter or Facebook or Instagram, you know the standard stuff of legacy social media, just to show that nostr is censorship resistant and that you don't have to use clients that perform these types of actions.
"Once these sorts of clients are introduced to the app stores the other apps that follow suit will probably become unavailable…"
Don’t think that could be an issue?
I just think we need all sorts of clients. Ones that are wide open. Ones that give users a wide variety of control. Ones that filter, whatever you want to call it. Show the full demonstration of the protocol and give users the ultimate choice to what type of experience they would like to have. The more choices we have, the better.
I don't think that'll be the case. They'll always be freedom-loving psychopaths like us that will pursue and die on this hill. But that doesn't mean the other solution shouldn't exist either.
I definitely agree there’s enuff of us that will die in that hill…
That would probably be client dependent in this type of scenario. But again, that's fine because it demonstrates the openness of the protocol where any client can do whatever they want to do. I think it all comes back to having a wide plethora and wide variety of user choice. Why should what I say or what you say dictate what another user does or how I use another application or how the developer should build the application. I'm all for ultimate user choice and ultimate developer choice. Again, we should have a wide variety of literally everything. Don't get confused by my ramblings or have them be viewed incorrectly. I don't want censorship. I hate censorship but I think some people do and I think some developers do. So, if those clients existed then we will be able to showcase the versatility of Nostr. Do you understand what I'm saying?

Let's build all of it.
Thanks brother.
Maximize for freedom
𝚁𝚢𝚊𝚗 🏴☠️🎶
You're free to post what you want.
Relay operators are free to host what they want.
You're free to host your own relay.
Users are free to block what they want.
Clients are free to block what they want.
Users are free to use whatever client they want.
View quoted note →
I say this out of love. Fuck off. You're telling me that you want people to come inside your house and scream at you about things you don't like? I thought you were a sovereign individual? LARPer.
What is the difference between "free speech" and "freedom of speech" ?
There’s plenty of chances for people to take sides on all these forkin’ issues as they pop up.
And hey, there’s always PubKey.
*cafeteria fight ensues*
WTF

When you post on a nostr relay, you have "free speech" or "freedom of speech" ?
🫂
fiatjaf living long enough to become the villain
Do you consider email spam filters to be censorship?
No. It's your own email server, you can do whatever you want.
But here we are talking about something else.
At a personal inbox level, yes block as many npubs as you want, and optionally don't be notified when/if they mention you. But
@fiatjaf likely misspoke, when typing: "block them from mentioning".?
But, the bridge WAY TOO FAR is blocking comments in the note's comment thread, as other users see it. These users have the ability to create an individual block list for themselves.
Imagine if White House Gov or pharmacy companies had the ability to censor descent at this level. The easy next logical step is an approved repliers list. This would be safe and effective, after all.
This is exactly how you Mastodon my Nostr, even if the sky is blue.
If I mute you for being a clown shoe that's not censorship. That's me being a sovereign individual over my own timeline. You can continue to speak and win and I can continue to see what I want and win. It's honestly this simple. Please understand both sides here.
And even there, it is more about "prior restraint". Even in the most free speech environments, if what you say angers and offends enough people, you lose your audience. That is inescapable, but many misunderstand and think free speech is being restricted.
No one threatened them before they said / posted their message. There are, however, potential consequences for posting or saying what they said / posted.
Okay, I think I missed what you meant in the first place.
What you are saying is that blocking the post of an user at the condition of the message being a reply/mention to another user is censorship(?).
That's currently how it is on the current centralized social media.
There is nothing to prevent users to broadcast their messages on alternative relays that won't support those specific NIPs, am I right?
Also, the third picture is talking about client moderation, not relay. I have a client I built for my meetup that anyone can post from but only a small list of npubs content is visible, that's moderation, not censorship
I had to look close to seeing it was not him....🤣🤣🤣🤣
This is funny .
You're definitely misreading the comment.
Maybe they're some sort of legal pressure and he's covering for future problems. "at least I tried".
No, he's just a glowie racist.
If you want to prevent nostr from successfully serving as a psy op to further the normalization of censorship, join me in trying to counter-filter the people responsible for the bullshit.
View quoted note →
He has been for a long time, but people kept ignoring it and letting it continue, like they'll probably do with this.
Easily solved if there are actually people other than me that want to solve it, though.
Right. At the end of the day, it's always been about running your own relay. We've said this for years. Just like running your one Bitcoin node.
The solution is to run your own relay. Always has been. Then you're your own outbox and inbox. I've done this for years now with HAVEN relay.
I run my own private relay, for personal stuff.
We are talking here about PUBLIC relays.
I love having a private relay and eventually I'll fix whatever's plaguing the public relay I set up, but when I do it's going to be limited to people I follow being able to write to it and it's only going to retain notes for a limited amount of time. Both are forms of censorship. People who make public relays available are surely free to do whatever they want with them?
The text was not written by me and is not really important, just watch the video
Then it fails back to an education issue perhaps?
>People who make public relays available are surely free to do whatever they want with them?
fiatjaf in that note do NOT refers to relays ability to filter or restrict npubs. That is undeniable feature and I agree with it. Not your relay - not your notes.
But fiatjaf was referring to ability of any user of that relay to delete replies or even ban a npub to reply or mention you on a public relay.
It's a big difference and a slippery slope.
watching is for your own benefit/understanding. If you remain willingly confused on the matter then that is up to yourself.
it appears you are also confused on the meaning of gaslighting
I think he worded it strangely but I think you jumped to a conclusion that is incorrect. Moderating your own inbox relay is how you control "your" view of the comments section... Not what others see at all.. For example, if I want a dirty spam filled comment section with damus airdrops, I can choose to construct my comment section feed to include free relays like nos.lol. then if I don't, I only use my relays that filter on WoT.
It's the same thing as a client mute list..
Other people that construct a view of the SAME comment sections will experience THEIR view of the nostr based on THEIR relays.. So.. it works really well. Using relays is no different than using clients, and for less than the cost of an X subscription you can run a relay for example with feeds.relay.tools and not get harassed or annoyed off of nostr like so many have in the past.
Your feed, your view, under your control. Obviously I encourage you to run your own relay so that I don't have to run one for you but I provide the services in case you don't want to do that work and would prefer to have a 3rd party in the loop.
running smaller relays is better. big relays are not just a free for all. look at primal, they censor, look at damus, it severely throttles by IP, look at nos, it feeds everything to LLMs and has sophisticated blocking.. none of which is transparent.
so your utopia view of these free big relays is flawed and would never work like I think you are thinking. better to lead by example and stop pretending a big free relay will have your interest in mind or be a good experience for everyone at once. by definition it will be more closed off because its under heavy load and doing its own things to cater to more people which would mean the experience degrades over time vs. running your own.
Read nip-65, fren 💛
lol isolated servers with 10 users. Bro that's Nostr with its 10 users. Mastodon servers do block each other a lot but who cares.
#NDN, when with nost-(r) ?
lol you would be the first one to ban monero posters from your relays
How does one of my relay blocking one of yours affect our communication?
i dont like big blocks
idk but people are going to want moderation and community tools. I think we're too early for that stuff be it's good to think about. Early in the sense of we don't even have enough users to worry about that kind of stuff outside of bots and complete nut jobs but I feel like blocks and mutes cover that.
It is indeed... Very true. Could you imagine a curated public facing Note for Plandemic 2030, on Nostr of all places.
lol if you dont like a client / relay, use other client / relay, if you cant find one, the answer is the usual : "build your own" lol this is beginning to be like mastodon. plus so much technical crap for only 10 human users on nostr, no wonder nobody want to join us
Being able to moderate what **you** see is not censorship. Are you daft?
So it's going in the exact way it's started, everyone being free to do about whatever they fuck they want to.
Did you even read the early specification? If not, why not?
It's been clear from day 0 that both clients and relays can do what they want.
What matters is that users can also do what they want.
If a client does something you don't want it to, why would you ever use that client?
Everyone can develop a client.
If you are a programmer, write your own fucking client. If you are not a programmer, use a client that does exactly what you want it to.
On a centralized platform, say Facebook or Twitter, the user is a slave to the platform owner. You can't pick your server, there is one server. You can hardly modify the client and doing so will likely breach some TOS agreement.
Nostr is described by many as "not a platform", but it is one ecosystem in the same way each big centralized platform is.
You can pick whatever relays you want and have your client interact with them however you want.
What you never had a right to do, on Nostr or anywhere else, is get people that don't want to read your stuff read your stuff. People can avoid you if they think you aren't worthy of their time.
Censorship hamper communication that is desired by the two participants.
If you write something on X and I want to read it, and you want me to read it, but it offends Elon Musks sweet fragile tiny little fefes, Elon Musk can ban that post.
If you write something on Nostr and I want to read it, I can read it.
The only scenario where a client will hide it from me is one where I use that client because I don't give a shit what you have to say and I actually don't want to read it.
Unless I'm retarded to the fucking point of using a client that acts against my interests. But no protocol solves the issue of morons acting against their own interests.
Every single Nostr relay that exists is because someone is running their own relay and just happens to also lets you shit post to it.
Nobody listens to you because you are a fucking moron.
The client is a slave to the user. It only hides things from the user if the users wants it to (or is retarded to the point of using a client that mistreats them).
Much retarded talk from you, never a line of code.
Stop waiting for others to listen to you.
Open your IDE, write the fucking code.
Talk is cheap.
Relays that keep all content will continue to exist.
I can run my own relay that allows everyone but you specifically and use that as my inbox. Nostr always allowed for that.
> We are talking here about PUBLIC relays.
There is no such thing.
Every relay belongs to someone.
On Mastodon admins can prevent you from reaching other accounts even if both you and the other person want to communicate.
This can only happen to retarded individuals on Nostr.
Don't use shit from app stores, for fuck's sake.
> like Primal
Primal is either not Nostr or the worst Nostr thing to exist.
sometimes you cant even read posts/replys from different relays/clients, too much technical crap, people just want to post/read, not everyone is as smart as you ser
What client was used to post something doesn't matter, unless that client is doing widely non-standard shit. In that case using such a client is an error from the poster, nothing that other clients can do about it.
On Nostr you can use multiple relays. Even without the outbox model we can communicate if we share at least one relay that allows us to communicate.
On Mastodon you depend on your one admin that you picked and we can communicate only if both of our admins allow us to. To address this you can have multiple Mastodon accounts, of course. The advantage of Nostr is you can reach others with just one account and no one person can ban you.
Tell that to the normies lmfao
We don't need to drag people to Nostr before they learn what a computer is.
I think they should learn what a computer is first, then come to Nostr.
> Your handle is familiar from Reddit 👋
That's because I have a Reddit account. Yeah, that's me.
The issue with Primal is much of what it does is decentralized. And some of its features don't even use the Nostr protocol.
It's, at least in part, a centralized platform that happens to use Nostr as a database.
> I'm not against moderation as long normal users are aware what is going on.
I think users should be fully in control.
I know I am because I am using my own client right now, so I know what it does, because I wrote it.
I'm not arguing everyone should write their own client, but everyone should be nearly in as much control as if they did.
In general, I think it would benefit the ecosystem if users of Nostr knew well how it works. The better they know and understand it, the better.
Insulting you isn't gaslighting.
Gaslighting requires lying or deception. I'm not deceiving you, you actually are a fucking idiot.
Write code or shut up. You are worthless, as a Nostr user and as a human being.
Basically "subscribing" to someone's mute list, selectively. Can totally be done
> Building my own client too, fully client side and will not use a special server, has to be smart because relays are dumb.
Same for me.
Just a static website, the only server it requires is a dumb HTTP server (it needs to be hosted, you can't just open the HTML file, but there is no server-side script) and, of course, Nostr relays.
And yes, it's not trivial to write one.
Very based that you are doing so.
Bro just report them as spam. That's what I do
Yesss we need a way to subscribe to others' blocklists
Then make a NIP for it and vibe code a client honestly. But isn't WoT basically the same?
What the hell are you talking about
You're annoying brother