Been reading up on the nostr protocol and comparing it to the DSP I wrote about in 2021. Many of the details seem to have been worked out brilliantly, but one thing that worries me is the reliance on volunteer nodes.
It would be nice if there was a business model for nodes and node competition at the protocol level.
As it is, I wonder if nostr can scale.
Login to reply
Replies (98)
There is! π many relays already require a subscription. But there are free options or you can run your own, of course
The monetization isnt necessarily part of protocol, but it doesnt need to be imo
Maybe Im wrong on that last part
Yeah, I saw that there are paid relays out there. The market will find a way, but the less the users have to deal with the better. Nodes are simple/dumb by design, so designing a business model for them so they are all competing on the same metric (data availability) shouldn't be tough.
There are many business models that support relay operators that already exist, from directly paying operators, brands offering it as a value add or having a relay that supports a client/app that earns revenue indirectly
As small as we are we already have over a thousand relays and could support millions of users
Loving the cap π«‘π«


#Alexandria @GitCitadel
Isn't that the beauty of Nostr? Anyone could design and code that tomorrow?
FOMO, wish I'd grabbed one with my order π
Two ways to business-ify relays :
- Subscription - filters, algos, data retention
- Ads - a free relay can serve up some digital vomit - don't like it, delete it from your list.
I think it'll scale.
Hello Ross! I'm a Brazilian fan of yours! Could you take a look at CriptoLivre, a website I created to bring together the best crypto services without KYC (aimed at the Brazilian public, inspired by kycnot.me)? https://criptolivre.online
Several business models for relays exist, such as subscriptions. nostr.wine is arguably our most successful paid relay with several relay types in their service catalog. Another would be services rendered for relay access as a packed service offering, such as nostrplebs.com and others.
Additionally, you don't have to run a large scale relay. Small community relays are the future thanks to NIP-65 outbix model. That's the future and many applications support it. Damus and Primal are the last major holdouts. Once they move over to this model, which they've previously mentioned doing so, the smaller community relay models will make more sense for everyone and decentralization goes up as a nice bonus.
The team @GitCitadel has had some success with starting to host a github replacement on Nostr. And, eventually, we will offer paid tiers for the #Alexandria project, an entirely new way to publish literally anything, with the intention to build a truly uncorruptable, hyperlinked knowledge base, and especially providing the means for breaking the back of the likes of the paywalled research journals, and eventually the whole publishing industry. All integrated with nostr's emphasis on community through interoperability.
We would welcome you to reach out and ask anything. Our resident media mogul, @Silberengel is asleep (she's in Germany) and will be very busy tomorrow (as many of us will be, since it is Easter), but... I'm usually responsive if you @ me.
Paid smart relays, such as algo relays. We have this model being worked on by @utxo the nostr user π§βπ»π.
Keychat is a chat app, built on Bitcoin ecash, Nostr protocol and Signal protocol. Keychat is inspired by the postal system β stamps, post offices, letters. Keychat uses Bitcoin ecash as stamps and Nostr relays as post offices. Keychat uses Signal protocol to ensure message encryption security and meta-data privacy.
Why should note hosting be commoditized? Can it even be commoditized? Compare it to renting servers. There isn't a single market price to host a web app. Every host has its own features, pricing structure, free tier etc.
Same with relays. Why standardize income source? The default might be to pay to have your notes hosted, but you could just as easily have a format where a relay invests in scouring and indexing all kinds of posts, and users pay to have a curated feed of the best posts of the day, or maybe even a personalized feed. You could see relays that charge for notes on demand you can't find elsewhere where you give the note ID and pay them to get the note back. I even imagine there will be relays that hold on to notes that people request to delete and will charge to see them like a paid wayback machine.
Even in the most common case where relays charge to host your notes, they will differentiate on many factors such as $/storage, $/bandwidth, uptime, speed, hosting location, redundancy, censorship resistance etc. Hosting is not something that can be commoditized.
One thing for certain though, and it's biggest difference between your concept is the ad funded relays. I don't believe this can ever gonna be a significant part of Nostr and the best thing about it. It will be a thing when there is a company that builds out a full stack with a client that works with their own relays but even then it's not necessary for any standard protocol to pay for it.
The client side decides what the users see. It always has last say in that field. Therefore, any attempt to fund a relay with ads will be fought off by client side filters if it ever gains significant market share.
Funny u say this because I literally messaged someone yesterday and said, that everything you were thinking of back in 2021 worked out with Nostr
Nostr can scale as is imo
The good news is that anyone can build on it
So if there is something you would like to try with relays β¦. A better wayβ¦ then do itπ
I completely agree with this, happy to have you with us. Have any ideas on how we can achieve this?
where can i get one?
Only one way to find out....
By onboarding millions creating a nostr client using the nostalgia of myspace 1.0...
And see if nostr can handle it.
π€·
Not exactly, but it would mean most of us would be using smaller relays
That's the idea, load would be spread , and not require any one relay to handle so much
This is what I wrote about back in 2021 if you want to take a look: https://rossulbricht.medium.com/decentralize-social-media-cc47dcfd4f99
The basic idea is that users would pay for content delivery, but it would happen under the hood at the protocol level and be super cheap and plentiful because of node competition (I called them "content servers" back then). Your average user wouldn't know or care about it, wouldn't have to shop around for private nodes or run their own.
But we donβt want ads and clicks model.
We are exhausted of this model.
running relays are pretty cheap, and with the outbox model each individual node doesn't have to be that beefy
this is like saying "the web won't work because web servers won't be sustainable without business models". yet tons of people run webservers for fun at a loss.
But who will run the relays? π
Thatβs quite interesting, thanks for sharing. And your right we have seen a lot of open projects being centralized and controlled by single entities a lot.
Glad to see you in this space. Do feel Nostr, has a chance at long term success?
When silk road paid relay :)
Yestr
WEN
1.5 years ago π₯Ή
GM. Yeah, we decided to tie specific relays from independent operators into our clients, as defaults. Users pay us and we pay the operators. If someone wants a custom instance of #Alexandria, our suppliers help them get their custom relay setup, and they then also pay the suppliers.
That way we carry the cost, and they can focus on the administration and security. We're using relays from @cloud fodder and @semisol.
And, of course, we encourage everyone to run a personal relay as a data store, like nostr-rs-relay or #Citrine π (for mobile). That way, they have their own archive and can use the functionality offline.
It makes a lot of sense to store your #ebooks on your phone or tablet, for instance.
Didn't get much sleep, unfortunately. π Maybe I'll have an Easter nap, later.
Yes, the #Alexandria client has the paid wss://theforest.nostr1.com (social) and the free wss://thecitadel.nostr1.com (publication/documentation) relays.
The #GitRepublic project, which includes the upcoming publicly-viewable git server, also includes the private, paid wss://gitcitadel.nostr1.com relay.
Each of the three relays are just the first of a set of relays, run by different professional operators, on different continents. Our income is currently over Geyserfund, zaps, and the paid relays. You pay us and we pay the relay operators.
We also self-host an instance of the #Realy relay, now, which is important to us for some of the features (RESTful API), and to have a non-strfry backup. We're debating adding that as publicly-readable, to our overall user landscape, as it would help with the #epaper implementation and add more redundancy.
I don't know, if you have heard of #Alexandria yet, @Ross Ulbricht. It's for books, magazines, research papers, scientific journals, technical specifications, treatise, etc.
https://next-alexandria.gitcitadel.eu/about
Zapvertizing is awesome!
Nostr relays are highly decentralized because we have negentropy and outbox models. That means its easier to cover the running costs, for every relay that isn't especially large and overrun with users.
You can't actually see most relays, as they're just little apps running on people's cell phones or laptops. I run the #Citrine π relay on my Android phone, and it has hundreds of books on it, takes up only 630 MB of space and doesn't noticeable increase my mobile bandwidth usage, since I sync it when in WiFi. Probably costs me a few euro-cents per month, and contains the notes that are relevant to me.
Sorry, this is also me. Forgot to switch to my dev account, before posting. As usual. π
π I also slept in, until 6:30 am. Truly decadent.
Happy Easter!
Told you they didn't read that post, they just welcomed you and zapped you! π π Love you man, you are an inspiration!
Cypherpunk Paolo Ardoino is building infrastructure that allows building decentralized apps that don't require servers to work (
). Their first app using this tech is a messenger called keet.io
It's not open source yet, but they plan to release the code to the public once fundaments are solid. If it works well, it will allow to build any type of decentralized apps on top of it and with proposed structure (no servers required) economically, imho, it's more reliable than nostr.


Holepunch
Holepunch
The Peer to Peer Company

Hasn't it been a tad slow to open-source though?
I guess this depends on how much of the fundaments they want to lay before public release.
For example, the Keet UX for now is not very good, so I can't even recommend it to anyone except early tech adopters. So if I was them (hole punch team), I would make it bit better before releasing the code. Building stuff that don't require servers have a lot unique challenges, so it takes time.
For now I'm just watching and cheering them. Idea is very good, but pending execution.
There are also some privacy issues as well, that needs to be resolved. All communication is encrypted, but because its p2p, there is a suspicion that peers leak their IPs to each other. On the other hand, privacy on Nostr is total downer. Still a lot of work in this space needs to be done.
I understand, still I think a good way to improve code is to open up.
If there are vulnerabilities, there's not much to hack at an alpha stage, so it would be a good trade off to open source.
From what I heard, Paolo is doing a lot operationally, maybe he's busy.
Sensory overload. Love it!
true story
I just remember he said they plan open source it. I agree with you, sooner you do it, better, at least from security stand point. But I guess there are trade offs. Dunno. Observing the project for now...
I am too. Aside keet are there any apps using holepunch?
Nice 'greed' typo
They recently released Node.js replacement that can be used in this no-server model. It's called Bare.
Pear
Introducing Bare: Actually run Javascript Everywhere
The Holepunch team has introduced Bare, a groundbreaking minimal JavaScript runtime designed for both desktop and mobile. Built to be fast, modular...
If you're building a product on Nostr, chances are high that you will also be providing a relay for the network
So the number of relays will increase along with the number of products
Good morningβοΈπ«‘! Hope your enjoying Easter. Also, I have a question: do you recommend leaving these blank?


#GM FREN HAVE A FABULOUS π DAY TODAY
There are subscription relays as well as many of us run our own private relays
And yet, there are already over 1,000 active relays. Pretty wild.
Some are paid, most are free. There are multiple commercial Nostr projects with an incentive to run relays. Primal runs two: one fully open, one for our premium users. We also run an open-source indexer and caching service.
In my view, Nostr scales through a combination of the outbox model (a.k.a. gossip), caching layers, and eventually, p2p transfers between clients. Nostr doesnβt need to rely on a single transport protocol. Every signed event stands on its own. Weβll make many copies of signed events and find different ways to move them around.
They're filters. Depends upon what you want to save.
Aaahh, gotcha. Thank you! How's Easter going?
@Ross Ulbricht I think the business model is bitcoin lightning and zaps and just have some 402 payment required like @Breez β‘οΈ now does with their SDK charging a few satoshis for transcendence
@Ross Ulbricht immediately asks the most important question imo. Do we ultimately need "pay to post" incentives? Will this be solved by other emergent business models (as we're already starting to see from companies like @primal ). My intuition is that other business models will subsidize and keep the network sufficiently decentralized (ie enough relays storing notes).
I also think that Nostr is more about the identity layer and ability to find peers or other communities via relay rendezvous points, at which point you can use whatever transport layer you want.
But we'll see... Probably the biggest open question in my mind. Wdyt?
View quoted note β
The relay data is valuable, can feed AIs, and more, there is no need to charge for subscription to relays. The relays will create their business models based on the data
I love that I can use my own relay, for my own notes. Similar to my own website, ran on my own hardware reliant only on my own internet connection.
If you spin up a Personal relay and only you use it, itβs the most valuable, specifically to you.
Ross you probably right nostr will not scale. But at least its another decent option. But ya without billionaires donations nostr won't last but that's true for a lot of software. If a company see a benefit from nostr they will create foundations and support.
.. pretty quick to form an opinion :-)
Thatβs good, because it doesnβt require arguments, the same way running your own node doesnβt require arguments
You either do it for your own benefit, or you donβt.
Running a relay for yourself and your friends I think is the way to go. Businesses as well, just larger.
Yes true . They stole cable and sell it . Imagine that .
But back to the main problem : what kind of business model that good for nostr β¦
I think at scale people will use one or two massive relays provided by a service, and then a couple volunteer nodes. Clients will likely provide a big relay, but other things like identifier, image hosting, search, etc., in exchange for a paid model or ads/boosted content. I think the clients will be doing a lot of heavy lifting in the future. We already see this happening with Primal.
So cool to see @Ross Ulbricht taking an interest in this little experiment
Oh yes, I do. That's why I am interested in understanding it and looking for possible weaknesses. I want it to succeed long-term, and the best way to ensure that is to look ahead, iterate and improve.
pretty much every single one of us has asked
"how is it going to scale"
after the first month
We are very happy to have you and appreciate your efforts. If you ever have any questions be sure to ask the community as well. πΆπ«
To be honest though when I first saw you had joined I thought you would probably attach your X to auto repost here then forget about us. Glad to be wrong.
Come by the Nostr Lounge in Vegas next month and chat with us if you have the time. We'll be in the open source area.
π«
Derek is the GOAT
The @GitCitadel team has been working on some very interesting projects that you might be interested in. I've been paying close attention and many others are beginning to, as well. ππ«‘
====================================
#7 β‘ Most Zapped Last Week
====================================
Nostrβs Value4Value (V4V) model is all about plebs directly rewarding creators for the value they receive, no middlemen fees, no ads, just pure community-driven support using sats via the Bitcoin Lightning Network. Thanks to by @PABLOF7z for providing this data. Here are the top zapped posts from last week, showcasing creators who received the most engagement:
π₯ Top 3: Most Zaps
1. Zaps Received: 708
Sats Earned: 1M
View quoted note β
2. Zaps Received: 155
Sats Earned: 42k
View quoted note β
3. Zaps Received: 90
Sats Earned: 50k
View quoted note β
π° Top 3: Most Sats
1. Sats Earned: 1M
Zaps Received: 708
View quoted note β
2. Sats Earned: 85k
Zaps Received: 41
View quoted note β
3. Sats Earned: 50k
Zaps Received: 90
View quoted note β
#most-zapped_nostr_recap
ZAPLIFE.LOL
A decentralized Craigslist running on Nostr

Easter Sunday was wonderful, and Mass this morning was pleasant, and then the Pope died.


not everything requires a business model. What was Bitcoin's business model 16 years ago?
I hadn't heard. Sorry, to hear thatπ«. Honestly, I knew nothing about his impact on catholicism or anything related. Was he a good or bad pope, in your opinion?
Dunno π€·ββοΈ
Mixed. Like all popes. They are all human.
Guess that papal infallibility doctrine is taken with a grain of salt.
There's some really fun relics in official doctrine in my experience.
Itβs great to have your pov in the space π
@jack mallers was selling them
They are great
Not gassing up Ross too much but the responses and engagement in here gives me, imagine if Satoshi popped up and discussed what's been going on the last decade vibes
View quoted note β
Paid relays are present, but thereβs still a lot of room for innovation
The nice thing is that nostr is truly decentralized, so it doesn't really need to "scale". You can self-host or uncle jim, in which case volunteer nodes are fine. The ones that most need a business model are indexers like purplepag.es, or hubs that new/non technical users can use to easily get started like relay.damus.io, and those can likely be subsidized by businesses built on nostr. Then there are services like nostr.wine, which charge subscriptions. There's also been some experimentation in usage based pricing facilitated by ecash. So I think the problem isn't currently solved, but there are lots of leads to pull when it becomes more necessary. And it will, as spam of various kinds becomes more of a problem
The idea seems similar to what @Keychat is building
Keychat has introduced the sats stamp concept, which is quite similar to what youβre talking about.π
Keychat is a chat app, built on Bitcoin ecash, Nostr protocol and Signal/MLS protocol.
Keychat is inspired by the postal system β stamps, post offices, letters.
Keychat uses Bitcoin ecash as stamps and Nostr relays as post offices.
Keychat uses Signal/MLS protocol to ensure message encryption security and meta-data privacy.


Keychat
Keychat - Super App for Humans and Agents.
Sovereign IDs, Bitcoin Wallet, Secure Chat, Mini Apps β all in Keychat.
For the love of god, please say "good morning" to @TKay!
We hope that Nostr relays can evolve into post offices that sustain themselves by collecting ecash sats stamps.