Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
By not voting, I am voting. My vote is that neither party has any legitimate claim on my consent. Legitimacy flows up from the governed, and I am withholding mine. When both doors open into the same room, declining to walk through either one is the clearest signal I have. #My2Sats

Replies (51)

Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
Bro, I heard that from a pulpit in our friends church over the weekend and I almost burst out in a chuckle.
Default avatar
stork 1 week ago
There is no win situation here
Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
The Long March succeeded because the Left actually built an alternative vision. Voting for a party that holds the line 2% slower isn't a strategy to undo 50 years of march imo. It's paying tribute to the machinery that manages the decline. Real low time preference is building parallel institutions, not consenting to the regime
Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
You're describing power. I'm talking about authority. A mugger controls the room, but he doesn't own my conscience. If my consent is a delusion, stop asking me to vote to prove it.
1. Bolsheviks want us all dead and want control of the military 2. Voting against bolsheviks at this point is playing defense and buying time to build parallel systems 3. It takes less than 15 mins every couple years to asymmetrically affect outcomes in their quest for (1) 4. When you're at war you battle on multiple fronts. You don't just fight where you want to fight. I honestly think the "sit this one out" mentality is a bit childish and is a psyop to just let the Bolsheviks get an upper hand. Ask the right wing Russians how that worked out for them in 1917.
APTea's avatar
APTea 1 week ago
This is unfortunately a naive idealism. In reality, this isn't what happens. A vote abstained is a vote for the people who explicitly and openly hate us.
Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
If voting actually acted as a brake pedal, your 15minute defense argument would make sense. But when both parties continuously expand the state, inflate the money, and fund the same leviathan, you aren't buying time at all. You’re funding the theater that manages the decline. Real low time preference warfare isn't relying on a ballot box managed by the regime to buy you time. It's building parallel institutions so strong that it doesn't matter which team is holding the gavel.
You're in war time and victory is uncertain. You don't have the luxury of only fighting where *you* want to fight. The path to victory building parallel institutions is a lot more straightforward and requires a lot less self defensive violence under republicans. And it's not really arguable imo. I would love to hear a sound counter argument but it all comes back to @Laser's post. View quoted note →
I think accelerationism feels good for the same reason not voting does. You are attempting to destroy or at least not support the system. Both *are* accelerationism, since not voting is voting for progressivism and voting for progressivism is accelerationism. Hard to see the victory in attempting to launch a revolution into destruction. History shows that that ends badly. If destruction is realized, then exit into parallel systems becomes a more vital imperative, but the path becomes ruinous and catastrophic for most. Iterative succession into the next world order is preferred so long as the caste of the sovereign individual is realized, IMHO.
And to give @Contra some ground, we don't know how much time voting for the slow liberals (🔴) buys us, and it's clear that reset is driving things more than anything right now, especially elections. Still: you don't squander even low leverage plays if you got em. You play the whole board as if you're going to get (divinely) lucky.
It changes the windy path but not the outcome. Our big levers are #Bitcoin, open models, and other freedom tech. Doesn't mean we should not play the smaller levers. The winding path is material.
Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
All about that “divine-sovereign” timing. At the end of the day, "We must obey God rather than men." Acts 5:29
Anarchy Edu's avatar
Anarchy Edu 1 week ago
Now Contra is not at all culpable for putting a human in a position to rule his neighbors by way of threats, coercion, and violence. He’s a smart dude.
If Contra is paying taxes, any taxes, then he *is* putting a human in a position to rule his neighbours by way of threats, coercion, and violence. He'd have to be a stupid dude to believe anything else. They don't need our ballot papers, that's just an amusing card game the robbers play amongst themselves. They *do* need our taxes, and y'all are feeding them.
Anarchy Edu's avatar
Anarchy Edu 1 week ago
Not voting for a master is in fact, not voting for a master.
I used to think authority (rather than just power) mattered to maybe a single-digit percentage of Western taxpayers. The was pre-COVID. We learned better. I doubt its more than one in ten thousand that care how the mugger came to be holding that gun.
Anarchy Edu's avatar
Anarchy Edu 1 week ago
I appreciate the sentiment and encouragement to defund the thugs. Nonetheless, getting robbed does not make the victim culpable for anything a thief does with the stolen loot. Each person is responsible for their own actions & being a victim of a crime is not committing a wrong. Again, please understand I do think it is *heroic* to resist the warmongering thugs of the state and I applaud anyone willing to not relinquish their money to this group.
Yes, and they do make it illegal, whenever they ban parties, disqualify candidates, change the rules, or annull results. Voting is mostly useless. But only mostly, else they wouldn't spent so many resources on controlling it.
Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
Taxes are taken under threat of the sword. A vote is given voluntarily. Conscience and moral consent remain unbowed.
Mostly agree, but I do think one has a duty to make being robbed as difficult and unrewarding as possible. Being a victim without meaningfully resisting is morally little different to funding evil on purpose.
Anarchy Edu's avatar
Anarchy Edu 1 week ago
The endorsement of politics within the church makes me cringe and sometimes furious… I wish I could chuckle, but I usually just want to start flipping tables :/
I can't respect that, its a distinction born of either cowardice or sophistry. "Profeta disarmato", to use Machiavelli's scornful term.
Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
I’m not convinced that taking a beating on taxes while quietly building real families and churches is "cowardice." It looks a lot more like surviving a siege. Real strength isn't throwing tantrums online about tax resistance while paying your taxes anyway.
Anarchy Edu's avatar
Anarchy Edu 1 week ago
I just don’t want to blame the victim …whether they choose to resist, be quiet, etc is their prerogative. I’m totally in support of encouraging resistance though, like you are. Thank you for that! I think you’ll like my favorite quote I’ll put below. …Anyone voluntarily joining the gang, donating to politicians, voting for politicians, or voting for taxes however, are absolutely to blame and are culpable to some degree. image
Fair, and all those things are important. But equally, I think "moral consent" is sophistry that would make our rulers giggle.
My votes are for people who DON'T want ID checks for accessing websites
If you can in your country write some true wishes of yourself on the ballot. The universe will recognise your signature. People realy need to take their energetic emanance more serious.
Not if you know what you actually control. In everything we do we get a choice. Doing it consciously or unconsciously. It's the hard part to find which it is.
Opting out of US Income Taxes is the best way to leave then hanging, and legal. All is in the IRC, but most will never put in the work... I posted redacted images of the last full refunds of fed and states I got, will probably do the same again for 2025 & 2023+24
Don’t stop. You and I don’t always agree, theologically, but I appreciate your candor and perspective.
Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
Thanks bro. Thats what makes this place great. Iron sharpening iron.
Most people who don't vote, do it out of laziness. By not voting, you are not expressing an opinion. You can't express an opinion by staying silent. Say your opinions out loud and VOTE for whoever aligns with you values. You analogy is flawed because you are not staying out of the room. It's more like choosing a ship's captain. You may choose not to vote, but at the end of the day, you are still ON that ship. The only difference is that you didn't get to pick a lesser evil. Imo, people who don't vote, don't get to complain about the destinos that the elected officials make Want to actually vote with your silence? Move to another country that aligns better with you
It's not gonna make it worse. What do you think will happen if people just stop voting? The government will be like "damn. Well. I guess the government is over. We should just step down". No. One single person will vote, someone will win, and the wheel will keep spinning
↑