Replies (66)
It ain’t much but it’s honest work.
Amazing!!
Proof of Work 🥹
How much bitcoin would you need to have dedicated to channel liquidity if you wanted to run a profitable and useful lightning routing node?
What do you mean by profitable? I've been running this node for 4 years. I don't try to do anything but run a node for my family. I don't sell channels either. I do use Lightning Terminal to auto balance fees for me. I don't do any management or babysitting any more. I haven't for the last 2 years. Ain't nobody got time for that!
Honestly, this is a question for
@LNBϟG. Their whole business is running profitable nodes.
Leave some sats for us too.
By profitable I do not mean running a business but just not losing sats by running it.
There are costs in opening and rebalancing channels and you would need to be routing a sufficient number of transactions to cover these costs.
But as you ended by saying "ain't no body got time for that" perhaps this is just a level of complexity I should not delve in to and I should just rely on a private channel to a LSP.
Satoshi power 💥
Opening channels and closing channels does have a cost association. Choosing good partners can help here.
I don't rebalance anymore. I find it easier or better to just juggle fees and to help liquidity move around. I do this with LITD now.
This is cleaner…
Haha can’t top the OG
In good conscience I have to chime in on this post. It's awesome the revenue that Derek is making, but for anyone thinking about standing up a routing node, the majority of nodes won't be profitable. There are cost associated to open channels, rebalancing, and most of all, force closes.
Here are my routing stats for approximately 5 months. What it doesn't show is that I'm around 150,000 sats in the red. Running a lightning node, in my opinion, is a great education in Bitcoin and contribution to the resiliency of the Lightning network. But save for the really large nodes, many won't be profitable.
Take that for what it's worth. I'm my mind the sats that I've "lost" aren't a loss at all but the best education/experience I've had in the space.

Derek Ross
My Lightning node earns generational wealth by routing transactions 🥹

View quoted note →
Is there a video or detailed explanation on how to do this step by step? I mean set you the lighting node to route transactions. 😃
How to setup a node?
This is yield on Bitcoin. ☝️
Provide a service and earn fees! Sold.
But be careful with your lightning node……
Is it eating up that amount of money in hardware and electricity cost and time spent on maintenance (which has value, too), though?
What has been your strategy for automating channel balancing?
How many channels are you running?
Welcome to the club!
I got less but my routing number are much lower, my fee per routing is much higher.

That kind of number formatting always boggles my mind. I have to think if it's 30, 30k or 30M
Anyway sir, good work on your sats earning node!
That's about my income, also. It's charity 😁
It's 30k
That's a funny question 😀
Use umbrel, that's the most simple and cheapest way - as far as I know
Huh, it's kinda less than tmi thought tbh

Cool. On a per hour basis, I see that's almost as much as you've been zapped for making this comment.
What's your setup?
I ran an Umbrel for 2.5+ years and built my own custom one a year ago.
About 30.
I don't rebalance any longer. I just use Lightning Terminal and that's it.
About $3 a month according to Google. Hardware was $100.
@BTC Sessions has some good videos on running Umbrel or StartOS on his YouTube.
nice. Any tips on how to set up one? What software to use, what kind of hardware, etc?
How?
Awesome 👌
Lol Derek.... post the costs :D :D :D :D
Derek Ross
My Lightning node earns generational wealth by routing transactions 🥹

View quoted note →
I will read about it
Awesome 😊
That’s ‘the Bitcoin ’yield’ that everyone is looking for, actually.
Genuine question: if I were to run a self-hosted lightning node for private channels for my family & myself on my desktop, what would happen if I periodically shut down the desktop overnight?
I’m looking into getting an umbrelOS/StartOS in the near future, but in the meantime to test it out, I’m curious to know the implications with running it on my desktop during the day & turning off the desktop overnight.
If you have poor uptime you want to choose good peers that are aware of your nodes habits and are okay with the downtime.
Your peers can always close or force close on you. Regular closes are fine. Force closes can lock up funds for a few weeks. Worst case scenario is your node is offline for multiple weeks during that force close window and does not attest to channel state in time and loses the funds in that channel.
Absolutely. I've said this before. It's not much, but you can earn fees for providing a service.
Its not about the fees, its about providing liquidity and strengthening the network. Keep on rocking in the free world
@Derek Ross I salute you
Derek Ross
My Lightning node earns generational wealth by routing transactions 🥹

View quoted note →
Use umbrel on raspberry with a 2TB USB SSD.
You can't be profitable just by routing. You need real businesses that supports the lightning payments.
I used Umbrel for 2.5+ years. It worked great. It's a solid product. I switched to a home grown solution because I wanted a little more freedom to run different apps.
But only if your peer lies to the Blockchain about the channel closing balance. Not many people have the skill to do this.
I did a couple years ago. I haven't used them in a while. It's a great tool though.
Me too, even compiled the BTC core and lnd myself - don't trust, verify 🙂 (if you can)
same, same, same.
U can dnld software on a sov. deck
Is that gross or net?
I've "earned" more than that on my node, but after on-chain fees (and a bit of rebalancing), I'm still in the red.
Is it too i/o intensive? can i use a NAS via NFS? Using NFS seems stabler than using external USB disks in raspberry pi.
So I’m assuming (with limited knowledge in lightning channels) the downside to this is that when my peers regularly close the channel d/t excessive downtime(s), I’d have to pay the default fee required to open a new channel every single time?
Indeed that would be another cost to consider when a channel peer closes on you.
The best peers can be relationships you already have. They will be more likely to give you inbound liquidity and less likely to close on you without at least a message in advance.
But hell with on chain fees where they are the juice will almost certainly be worth the squeeze. With tooling where it is today too now is probably the best time ever to experiment with lightning.
Just the initial load of the Blockchain, it's about 600 GB. Later it's just ln gossip and about a block every 10 minutes 🌞
It's stable with external power supply at the SSD
You mean, Lightning Terminal does this for you?
I could do the initial load in better hardware, then just transfer it to the NAS and configure the r-pi to point to it. might work... Is the full blockchain needed? can't i use the feature where bitcoind keeps only the last few blocks? (forgot the name of the feature)
yes that works, I've also copied the Blockchain around several times. Not sure about the "partial BC" feature, it's not recommended cause you can't verify completely.