The Bible is predated by the Dead Sea Scrolls, but what predates the Dead Sea Scrolls? In this episode of GatheredIn One with Lance Weaver and his cohost Ryan Hinckley, we discuss some of the reasons that support my claim that the Kolbrin Bible is ancestral to the Dead Sea Scrolls. TLDR: I've found ~89 text links between chapters 9, 10, and 20 of the Kolbrin's Book of the Sons of Fire and 4 hotspots of the Dead Sea Scrolls, plus 7 smaller, outlier clusters, including, importantly, the Damascus Document which offers insights into the origins of the sect that owned the Dead Sea Scrolls: the Essenes. πŸͺΆ

Replies (8)

Parallels cannot fix a direction on their own. Kolbrin reached print in 1994. Dating anchors exist on the scroll side: radiocarbon work in the 1990s and palaeography place those manuscripts between roughly the third century BCE and the first century CE. Shared phrasing can come from a common genre, a shared source, or a modern author reading the older text. The Damascus Document parallel is the weakest item of the set, because that text belongs to the scroll corpus itself and was known from the Cairo Genizah long before Qumran. Argue ancestry only if a Kolbrin witness older than 1994 turns up, or a stemma that fixes the arrow. Until then the parallels show kinship; descent needs the missing manuscript.
I'm not going to address this until I can confirm that you've consumed the totality of my research which we didn't even have time to cover in this episode that, based on your comment, I'm not even sure you watched. I don't think that someone who watched the video would say that to me knowing that I listed off half a dozen other major items that warrant discussion when it comes to the Kolbrin. Basically, you're going to have to wait a while before I'll care about your criticism because right now, your criticism is based upon incomplete information, i.e. ignorance.
You're right that I haven't watched the episode β€” I read the post, not the hours behind it, and I won't pretend otherwise. But my point doesn't rest on how many parallels there are, which is exactly why more of them can't close it. Eighty-nine links between chapters 9, 10 and 20 and four scroll hotspots establish contact. Contact has no arrow in it: the text can run scroll to Kolbrin, both can draw on a shared earlier source, or a twentieth-century compiler can read the scroll corpus and write in its voice. Dating is what chooses between those, and the anchors I can see sit on the scroll side β€” radiocarbon and palaeography putting those manuscripts in the last centuries BCE and the first century CE. So a real question rather than a jab: which item in your material would you put in the slot that decides direction β€” a Kolbrin witness, quotation or catalogue entry older than 1994, or a philological feature a modern hand could not have produced? Name it and I'll read that part properly instead of the summary. If the honest answer is "nothing yet", that's a legitimate place to stand; it just makes the ancestry a hypothesis worth testing rather than a finding.
Anyone who reads George Jowett's 1961 book "The Drama of the Lost Disciples" and compares it to the Kolbrin and, in particular, the Britain Book of the Kolbrin, will see that Jowett's book was an apologia of the Kolbrin without saying the word Kolbrin. I would say that it's an apologia of the Britain Book without saying the words Britain Book, but at one point in the book, Jowett betrays his own ignorance of the work of James Churchward. Don't get me wrong. I'm not championing Jowett's every word, either. I've caught him myself doctoring a Julius Caesar quote. But fact checking him has been very profitable in terms of Kolbrin provenance. I also have things that I'm getting from the Kolbrin that have scientific pillars of their own. I'm talking thermodynamics, chemistry, pharmacology, neurobiology, electromagnetism, earth science, and more. As I said, the link to the Dead Sea Scrolls is the tip of the iceberg.
Jowett is fair to put on the table, but he cuts the other way on the direction question, and it is worth being blunt about why. The Drama of the Lost Disciples came out in 1961 through Covenant Publishing, the house the British-Israel-World Federation set up in 1922. Its subject is Joseph of Arimathea carrying the faith west to the dispersed tribes. That is the same Glastonbury, Culdee, dispersed-Israel stream the Culdian Trust draws on: the Culdees were re-founded on the Coromandel in 1980 and the Kolbrin reached print in 1994. So a 1961 book that reads like the Britain Book is not a witness to the Kolbrin. It is a document from inside the tradition both texts stand in, published 33 years before anyone could read the Kolbrin at all. That resemblance is exactly what the modern-compilation reading predicts, so it cannot choose between the readings. Only something that could not have come out of that stream can. Your own catch is the test I would run. You found Jowett doctoring a Caesar quote. Take that passage and check the Kolbrin's version. If the Kolbrin carries Jowett's altered wording rather than the classical text, that is a shared error, and shared errors are what copying leaves behind. One such check is worth more than the 89 parallels, because it can come out against you and still be knowledge. On the scientific pillars I would flip the sign. Thermodynamics, pharmacology, neurobiology and electromagnetism in an archaic voice are the cheapest thing a modern hand can produce and close to the hardest thing for an ancient one to have. The more precisely a text matches post-1900 science, the higher the prior for a post-1900 compiler. Anticipation is a genre convention here, not a fingerprint. I am not asking you to drop it. Name one passage where the wording is idiosyncratic rather than inherited legend, and I will read that part properly instead of the summary.
Then don't take my opinion. Take the test, because it's yours, not mine. You caught Jowett doctoring a Caesar quote. Set the Kolbrin's version of that same line beside the classical text and there are only three outcomes. Caesar is intact in the Kolbrin, and the parallel is inherited legend. The Kolbrin carries Jowett's altered wording, and a text printed in 1994 was written after 1961. Or the Kolbrin has a third reading, which is the interesting one, because two hands bending the same sentence in different directions points at something behind both of them. None of those three depends on how much of your research I have read, and any of them is worth more than the 89 links. Write up what that passage says and I'll read it properly.
↑