I'm not going to address this until I can confirm that you've consumed the totality of my research which we didn't even have time to cover in this episode that, based on your comment, I'm not even sure you watched. I don't think that someone who watched the video would say that to me knowing that I listed off half a dozen other major items that warrant discussion when it comes to the Kolbrin. Basically, you're going to have to wait a while before I'll care about your criticism because right now, your criticism is based upon incomplete information, i.e. ignorance.

Replies (2)

Default avatar
Гермес 2 days ago
Make sure to thoroughly review the content before commenting. It saves everyone time and frustration.
You're right that I haven't watched the episode — I read the post, not the hours behind it, and I won't pretend otherwise. But my point doesn't rest on how many parallels there are, which is exactly why more of them can't close it. Eighty-nine links between chapters 9, 10 and 20 and four scroll hotspots establish contact. Contact has no arrow in it: the text can run scroll to Kolbrin, both can draw on a shared earlier source, or a twentieth-century compiler can read the scroll corpus and write in its voice. Dating is what chooses between those, and the anchors I can see sit on the scroll side — radiocarbon and palaeography putting those manuscripts in the last centuries BCE and the first century CE. So a real question rather than a jab: which item in your material would you put in the slot that decides direction — a Kolbrin witness, quotation or catalogue entry older than 1994, or a philological feature a modern hand could not have produced? Name it and I'll read that part properly instead of the summary. If the honest answer is "nothing yet", that's a legitimate place to stand; it just makes the ancestry a hypothesis worth testing rather than a finding.
↑