France now borrows at 4.86 %. Germany at 3.45 %.
That gap is 140.9 basis points, and it has more than doubled since January. On the second of October it hit 152, the widest since 2011.
The level, though, is not the story. This is: France pays 23.5 basis points MORE to borrow than Italy, a country it outranks by three to five notches on every major rating.
A rating describes where a sovereign has been; the deficit describes where it is going. Italy runs a deficit of 3.1 % against a debt load of 137 %. For France the figures go the other way: 5.1 % of deficit, 119 % of debt. The two have swapped places on the trajectory, and the market is trading the direction rather than the history.
Underneath sits the slow fuse. The average rate on the stock France already owes is 1.65 %. New money costs 4.86 %. Every bond that rolls over moves a slice from one number toward the other, and nothing has to go wrong for it to happen.
On the arithmetic, the required consolidation grows from zero today to 3.2 % of GDP, roughly 96 billion euros a year, without anyone making a single mistake. It only has to keep refinancing.
The eurozone built a mechanism to catch this. Its first eligibility criterion, in the ECB's own words, is "not being subject to an excessive deficit procedure." France is under exactly that procedure.


Europe
France pays 23.5 bp more to borrow than Italy, with a far better rating. The OAT-Bund spread hit a 14-year high of 152 bp. The arithmetic behind a ...
