Replies (96)

I'm neither. Digital private money exists its called Monero. You can have both that's why people like me are so excited about Monero and other privacy projects like Ethereum Railgun, Litecoin MWEB, Samurai Wallet, etc. You can get that level of privacy in Bitcoin too, it just requires extreme caution, and a high level of study of chainalysis and network level deanonymization.
ive had this conversation with him and didn't get upset like you say, everybody needs dollars dude just wants to argue
I understand your preference for Bitcoin. I just find its too risky, expensive (TX and swap fees) and labor intensive to maintain a similar level of privacy that Monero gives you by default thus I prefer Monero. I believe defaults are important and value privacy highly thus the more private by default currency is superior to me. I understand that you disagree since your priorities are different. We're different people so it's logical that we're not going to see eye to eye on everything.
BTC_P2P's avatar
BTC_P2P 11 months ago
To say that gold proved demand for private money is either delusional or disingenuous. If you can’t admit that then I’m leaning toward delusion. I don’t care about privacy and I don’t need it. 99.9% of people don’t care about privacy and don’t need it. I have non KYC UTXO’s and nobody can stop me from doing whatever I want with them. But in daily life there is zero demand for private transactions. I do care about money that is auditable, finite, secure and that is clearly winning the global competition for money and SoV. This is Bitcoin. Monero fails on these criteria.
right on que the "surveillance is normal" cope from the maxis people didn't need to "demand privacy" they took it for granted *because it was normalized*
BTC_P2P's avatar
BTC_P2P 11 months ago
Public ledger is a better trade off than an unauditable supply and unlimited supply. The market has spoken. Cry harder.
Since you don't care about privacy. Can you put here for eternity: - full legal name - date of birth - residential address - mugshot - net worth - all of your bitcoin addresses Put your actions in line with your words, and do it. If you won't, shut the fuck up and stop talking bullshit. Thank you.
BTC_P2P's avatar
BTC_P2P 11 months ago
I’m speaking about my transactions on a public ledger. I don’t care. Nobody can stop me from signing a tx and that’s what matters.
Ah, ok then. So now it's only FINANCIAL privacy you don't care about. Post your bitcoin addresses, since you don't care about privacy. And how many bitcoin do you own in total, since you don't care about privacy, will you share? Please also post your bank account number. You know, for lulz, since you don't care about privacy.
BTC_P2P's avatar
BTC_P2P 11 months ago
Figure it out mami. That’s exactly why I don’t care about my transactions going on a public ledger. You will never figure out what UTXOs are mine and you can never stop me from transacting. IDGAF that they’re public. Do something about it or STFU 😂😂
And to that I'd say you're a bit retarded 😁 Do you understand anything, anything at all about computer networks, mass surveillance and the like? Are you running your own electrum server? Probably not. Are you connecting to an electrum server over Tor or Nym? Probably not. So, in all likelihood, all your wallet addresses are already neatly mapped to your IP which is tied to your identity because you leak the whole thing every time you connect your wallet to the internet. And it only takes once. Your argument is as "brilliant" as if there was a bunch of webcams inside your house and you think you're safe because I don't know your IP address. Yeah, I don't, but someone does. Furthermore, imagine the cam streams are not encrypted. You boadt of being safe because I am not your ISP or the NSA so I can't easily intercept the data stream. Fair, but you are missing the point. Your setup is badly designed. Why do you think every financial service runs behind TLS? So that people can't intercept it. And here you are, singing like a proud ignorant cock, while you dig your own hole deeper and deeper with each transaction you make. If nothing else, one day you will make a mistake, and because your transaction history is permanent, it can be RETROACTIVELY deanonymized when that day comes. Honestly, all of this is so glaringly obvious that I find it more than a bit troublesome that there are people who can't see it. Turns out it's most of them, so at least you're in good company.
BTC_P2P's avatar
BTC_P2P 11 months ago
Doxx my UTXOs right now. Then stop my txs. Prove how flawed bitcoin is right now for everyone ⏳
As I thought, you're a fool. The nuance - no, actually, the entire point - of my carefully crafted argument is entirely lost on you, I will waste no more time here.
I mean if you wanna be poor for the rest of your life that’s fine. Grocery prices went up again recently. Have fun finding someone to buy monero off you to get your bills paid. You know that rent payment isn’t going to be made in monero. Most monero bros will end up converting their monero to bitcoin and then converting that to dollars to survive. You’re not different from Bitcoiners in the way you pay your bills. Just more stupid by throwing away gains away just to feel superior.
you don't understand bro you need to do the trampoline routing triple backflip into a cashu mint and then laugh at the coinjoin devs when they go to jail while you're not busy monitoring a fee chart or having sex with your dog. 99% of transactions don't need sovereignty. this is the best money. HFSP tick tock next block laser eyes
Lol. Honestly if they just tried Monero they'd feel so free from having to deal with the paranoia of staying private on Bitcoin.
You keep harping on this. We all pay our rent or mortgage by ACH transfers or some other fiat system. This isn't a gotcha, I'm actually confused what your point is with it.
Bitcoin has a mining centralization problem too buddy, it's a vulnerability to all PoW coins. Monero wasn't 51% attacked, it was about 37% at peak and was a selfish mining attack. If just two BTC pools colluded they could perform the same attack Bitcoins mining has a larger problem due to ASICS. Only one manufacturer currently makes the most competitive chips to mine Bitcoin which is a major supply chain centralization factor and a backdoor vulnerability. Monero uses RandomX which makes all CPUs roughly as efficient as each other. You could mine on a 20 year old laptop, a VPS or a dedicated server.
Yeah my mortgage being in my name and being forced to pay with fiat is a major privacy concern. Unfortunately in the US it's mandatory unless you create an LLC structure and manage to get a loan via the LLC. I didnt have the capital or the bandwidth for a move like that when I bought so I didn't. I plan to in the distant future though. The most private way I could think of paying my mortgage is a money order paid in cash, this is more expensive, slower and less secure however and since the mortgage is in my name I decided the tradeoff was insufficient. Idk what this has to do with Monero's privacy though you keep bringing this up but it's a major goalpost shift that is ultimately a non sequitur to the main argument.
Some people don't care about money more than privacy. I'm one of them. I've decided since you can die and keep your dignity, but can't die and keep your money, I value dignity more. To me, my privacy is my dignity. You can disagree with this, understandably, but that's just what I believe.
Monero is about proprotionately secure to Bitcoin in terms of energy to market cap. The hashrate is way lower because RandomX is intentionally less efficient. I had another reply I made weeks ago that does the math to prove this. This isn't a gotcha, that same major vulnerability of state intelligence exists in both. Actually I'd argue it's worse in Bitcoin due to the single manufacturer ASIC issue I previously discussed. It's such a security concern than the US has declared concern over China's potential influence on this ASIC manufacturing.
Yeah it's likely a big portion is. Not moral but it's a consequence of RandomX. It's actually good for decentralization oddly enough. What's the point?
Why can't you care about both? Bitcoin can be great money and private. And it seems your dignity doesn't matter when you pay your mortgage
Yeah it's not ideal but PoW is what we got. Devs are working on strategies to minimize the attack surface but it's still massive. Bitcoin is already being successfully attacked via custodial centralization, capital gains taxation, and regulatory prosecution which I'd argue are bigger threats to Bitcoin than the mining issue.
Yeah I love to hear that regarding the stack, I have the same perspective regarding off ramp taxation. It's one of my favorite features of Monero. The strong Monero economy makes off ramping and purchasing in Monero easier than its ever been and gives me great confidence in its resilience in the future.
How do you buy your Bitcoin? Is it less asinine than what I suggested? My response regarding registered mail was specifically in response to mail theft in which I acknowledged that you could mail cash with no return address but incur greater risk. Not asinine, quite calculated and appropriately private considering risks.
If you don't have proxy=127.0.0.1:9050 (or :4447 for i2p) in your Bitcoin configuration file, you're doxxing all your transactions to your nodes IP since Bitcoin nodes don't have Dandelion++. You said you have the electrum server over Tor but didn't mention if your core daemon was routed behind Tor or I2P.
Crypto isn't about holding its about spending. It's usage is the value. I spend Litecoin if someone requests litecoin, same for ERC20 tokens. Funny you leave out gold and silver and instead pick the past currencies that haven't retained value. Gold and silver have existed as money for thousands of years. They have advantages and drawbacks. It is what it is.
Because nearly all "Monero guys" recognize Bitcoins utility, especially lightning. It's also a "when in Rome" thing. Nostr was built for zaps so we embrace the zaps.
So true. Donations are usually tax exempt in most nations too. Low value donations are basically the lowest risk factor form of transaction in terms of surveillance.
Here have more zaps as a thank you for this giant conversation. You've genuinely made my night, I'm not joking this has been awesome.
Default avatar
npub149zy...mrez 11 months ago
If you have a UTXO of say 1 BTC, spend 0.01 BTC, then the receiver and everyone in the world simply sees your .99 change address. Further with traceability, all future spends and past spends are easily attributable to you via the billion dollar blockchain surveillance industry with 12+ years of increasing sophisticated spying techniques.
Default avatar
npub1gwfp...xxee 11 months ago
it won't. monero solves a narrow use-case (absolute digital cash) but most people don't give a damn about on-chain privacy; they want a scarce, credibly neutral digital asset that preserves value **at scale** → bitcoin already owns that mindshare. downside: - tail-emission kills "digital gold" hardness - dev tax & centralised maint squad - hard-fork churn every upgrade → "upgrade or die" bitcoin keeps absorbing hashpower, liquidity, mindshare; privacy can bolt-on where needed (cj, silent payments, lightning point-knew schemes). so xmr survives, maybe even carves out a dark-market niche, but win state? nah, btc absorbs it.
oh hey didn't you accuse ME of always jumping into threads to start fights with maxis? your self-awareness is shit 😂 worse than your intellectual consistency
no. stop with the AI slop and dyor. there is no "dev tax" what is Core except a "centralized main squad" (admittedly larger project of course) and how does tail emissions kill "digital gold hardiness?" Moneros rate of supply inflatation is already ½-¼ golds and will only decrease. Theres no reason monero can't be digital gold. But completely agree on the network effect points you mention. No contest there.
👻's avatar
👻 11 months ago
Also, gold also has an increased supply, slight inflation rate. Also since tail emission of 0.6 divided by total current supply trends to zero over time, a decreased rate over time. in my opinion it looks like if anything xmr has more of a common trait with gold.
Default avatar
npub1gwfp...xxee 11 months ago
once perma-mining rewards hit zero, btc miners live off fees + block premium. xmr keeps 0.6 xmr tail forever—steady “printer” for baseline security. that prevents fee collapse in out-years but also nixes the hard-21M meme. fair trade-off for cash-like coin, *less* for “digital gold” narrative that lives on absolute scarcity. rest checks out: no “dev tax”, just a voluntary community FFS; core’s also a klatch of gatekeepers. still, bitcoin’s first-mover marsh of liquidity, integrations, derivatives blows xmr’s pro-privacy edge on raw network-effect reality. monero survives for its niche, bitcoin bleeds in everyone looking for the number-go-up store-of-value.
BTC_P2P's avatar
BTC_P2P 11 months ago
All these monero shills are LLMs. They have no concept of time but will waste anyone who engages with them forever. Such a stupid thread. Never again.
👻's avatar
👻 11 months ago
I just happened to stumble upon this thread. I'm also an xmr fan and rest assured I'm real.
Kanzan is actually a meditation maxi. He just doesn’t do it right that’s why he’s always so grumpy and unpleasant 😂 Great tutorial hope this helps him do it correctly lmao
Default avatar
Deleted Account 11 months ago
I actually like him and I tease him about shit from time. Wasn’t expecting a full meltdown haha 🤪
But more gains and good privacy if you aren’t lazy. Are you goin to present any new points or am I just going to keep repeating the same shit until I end up muting every last monero bro on nostr 😂
BTC_P2P's avatar
BTC_P2P 11 months ago
Lightning is how I buy gift cards. Very fast, very low cost and good privacy. And I really don’t give a fuck about privacy for my REI gift card purchase.
Default avatar
npub1tn0q...rk3w 11 months ago
So you either are using a custodial LN setup (at which point you could just use PayPal/Venmo to pay for this stuff) or if you actually use a Delft custodial solution your setup is much more complicated and less reliable then just using Monero. Either way, you payed more then a cent for your transaction (most likely), so you payed much more than me ;)
Default avatar
npub1tn0q...rk3w 11 months ago
For someone that got into crypto a year ago that wouldn't be true. (BTC - 10%, XMR +100%) Not everyone is in crypto since 2010. Privacy in BTC is expensive and cumbersome. Privacy in Monero is cheap and easy to use. More and more people realize this, that's why Monero displaced BTC on darknet markets and also rivals it on legal markets (for some numbers on that check the following message from me: )
Default avatar
npub149zy...mrez 11 months ago
Just an example... Also if you're broke just say so. (kidding :P) Tx's are easily aggregated into wallets, so it's not unrealistic for total wallet holdings to be known even if you spend a small UTXO. Lightning tx's can be linked to the UTXO used to open the channel. Network surveillance, traffic/amount correlations, and data from the large liquidity providers (Who are CEXs like Binance or other doxxed entities that must comply with blockchain Intel companies). But for fun let's say specific methods are unknown or unclear. In 2020 IRS paid out $500,000+ to two blockchain surveillance firms to work on tracing (breaking the privacy) of Bitcoin layer 2s - Lightning in specific. So at least realize that highly capable adverseries that receive hefty amounts of gov. funding have been working on these attacks for some time.
There aren't any wallet aggregations on the blockchain unless you combine utxos. They do chainalysis on monero too. This argument doesn't prove anything. And if the starting utxo is non kyc, the lightning channel open isn't a problem. Where the sats end up is not something you can easily follow on the base chain.
Default avatar
npub149zy...mrez 11 months ago
"There aren't any wallet aggregations on the blockchain unless you combine utxos." Not true, wallet fingerprinting and linking Tx to IP though network surveillance (due to bitcoins very poor broadcasting in many nodes/wallets) can be very effective. "They do chainalysis on monero too." Yes they do. Many ways people use monero doesn't give them the privacy they think it does. For example, instantly swapping in and out of xmr to 'wash' coins. Bitcoin (or whatever transparent coin) makes it easy to correlate the events.
Ehh not really. Still pretty hard to track the sats once they go into lightning. It's just ideal that cuckbase doesn't know you have any sats at all.
what is this horseshit? in my tradition we sit out in the freezing cold and hit each other with sticks when we get drowsy keep your new age watered-down crap, its not doing anyone any good anyway.
DrZhivago's avatar
DrZhivago 11 months ago
Not caring about privacy is advocating for rape. Not caring about financial privacy is advocating for rape, with condoms.
And monero doesn’t scale so here we are. Do I put my faith in a money that won’t ever be highly adopted or do I put it in a superior money with mass adoption and tons of building going on? Cashu, liquid, and lightning all offer different things with different tradeoffs. And I expect more options in the future. It’s cute that you think I’d actually read all that. Start with first principles. You people love to get ahead of yourselves. Provide a good reason as to why monero will win as money first. Otherwise I’ll keep working to improve my own privacy with the better money. In the event of a currency collapse, I would put myself and family in tremendous risk by holding a currency no one wants.
↑