Honestly, Iβm a bit confused by the βNostr is for everyone ( normies included) / we welcome normiesβ narrative sometimes. Because in practice, it doesnβt really feel built for that. And when someone points that out, the response is often βrun your own relayβ or similar.
But most normal users donβt want to run infrastructure, manage relays, or deal with technical setup for basic social use. They just want something that works out of the box. So Iβm trying to understand what that narrative actually means in reality. Is Nostr really aiming for mainstream users, or is it mainly a space for developers and more technical users? To me, those two goals feel quite different, and Iβm just trying to make sense of the gap between the messaging and the actual user experience.
Login to reply
Replies (13)
People who say βrun your own relayβ donβt know what they are talking about.
There's a lot of gaslighting. And then anyone who tries to make something different or call out issues gets shit on. @utxo the webmaster π§βπ» is a great example. I didn't like what he did with Wisp and I've given him playful shit about it, but there are people who genuinely think that their way is the only way and anything else is an attack on the user. The result is a thing built for relatively no one on the planet right now. I'm a proponent of options so people can flow into the UX and tradeoffs they want. You can't have that if no one is allowed to think differently.
Try
and let me know if you think it works for normies
If you're using Amethyst that's literally the most technical client out there, besides nak

Wisp
Wisp β Social that's actually fun again
Your group chat, your favorite creators, your money β in one app. Download Wisp free for Android.
Yes it's possible, many notes didn't survive all the relays that have come and gone. I too am missing many notes. But any decentralized network will have this issue, at some point someone has to pay to store data
I donβt think paying is a problem. Personally, I wouldnβt mind paying a monthly fee for a relay where the operator is known and transparent... people like you, JB, Vito, and others who donβt hide behind anonymity.
I like knowing who Iβm trusting with my data and who is actually running the service. To me, that doesnβt feel more centralized, it feels more credible and accountable.
I also think many βnormiesβ would feel the same way. Thereβs a level of comfort in transparency that anonymity doesnβt always provide, especially when it comes to trust and data storage. In todayβs world, people often associate anonymity with suspicion rather than trust.
So for me, visible identity builds confidence, not the other way around.
Yes, but also I think probably 80% of all the value is in recent notes, which nostr does extremely reliably for free, it's a trade-off. I don't think losing some old notes is a deal breaker for most people
Its all how you personally see it... i see it a bit different... i think its important that past is recorded and not ereased... π€·ββοΈβ¨οΈ Dont you think the structure of nostr isnt possible to improve to that point of everything to stand firmly? I think every problem has a solution...
There are relays you can pay for now that offer better assurances if this is important to you
run your relay citrine π
dude, #NDN at last..
when...
we all pay for our internet lines already.
who in the fucking rats ass ever came up with the idea of suddenly differentiating nodes on the edges that once upon a time we all were, and these days maybe even are increasingly again with more and more fibre lines... so create a fully integrated or plugin and modules based extendabe single piece of software already that integrates storing the bits caching and redistributing. skip the relay and server nonsense already, everbody can long ago be a relay and be a server. sigh. seriously. whe nurture hige datacenters and hyeprscalers to run your relays when you already have an ip address in this thing called internet and the whole idea was neutral and robust packet routing right from the start. tcp ip anonye? sigh
Thatβs why utxo built wisp. Heβs trying to make the experience more newbie friendly
It's really not for none technical people
Ahahaha shame, everyone's trying their best