Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
Let’s play a game. Name a single conservative administration in the last seventy years that actually shrank the federal government. Name one that abolished a major federal agency, balanced the budget, repealed the income tax, or shut down the fiat money printer. Name one that stopped the expansion of the surveillance state, brought the troops home for good, or dismantled the administrative apparatus that regulates your family, your business, and your church. You can't. Because the game is rigged, and the board only moves in one direction. The Left’s job in the uniparty is to push the throttle forward, expanding state power and codifying open rebellion against God’s order. The Right’s job is to act as the brake pad, slowing the pace just enough to give you the illusion of defense, while quietly ratifying every single expansion once they take office. The Left builds the leviathan. The Right manages it and tells you to be grateful it’s not worse. That’s why the Right is just as dangerous. It functions as a containment vessel for Christian resistance. It takes men who ought to be building parallel institutions, governing their homes, and holding local magistrates accountable, and convinces them to spend their energy, money, and moral authority begging a manager to run the prison slightly better. When both options expand the same machine, refusing to play isn't quitting. It’s realizing the game was designed to make you lose. This is my humble opinion and you’re free to disagree.

Replies (20)

This administration has reduced the number of federal employees dramatically and has ended USAID. Spending is still up dramatically and there's plenty else to critique, but shrinking the government has occurred in at least one sense.
Fabregas's avatar
Fabregas 1 week ago
A Esquerda é representada pelo modelo cubano de governo, ou seja, só miséria com um pouco de liberdade geográfica. A Direita representada é representada pelo modelo chinês de governo, com controle total, mesmo com alguma possibilidade de prosperidade pequena
Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
Shifting payroll from civil servants to private contractors, military apparatus, or intelligence budgets while total spending rises isn't "shrinking government." It’s restructuring the managerial class. If the state spends more money, wields more power, controls more capital, and inflates the currency faster than before, firing bureaucrats isn't dismantling the leviathan, it's streamlining it. A leaner corporate state with a bigger budget isn't smaller authority; it's just more concentrated leverage. Pruning a branch while feeding the root isn't shrinking the tree.
Contra's avatar
Contra 1 week ago
Exactly. I’m waiting for a coherent and logical response against what my OP claimed.
I'm not in disagreement, but even trimming that many people from the federal payroll is much more than we usually get. I'm certainly not trying to argue that you should vote for these people.
"Conservatism" today is only really about conserving the post war liberal world order. You can really chalk it up to those memes where republicans will be saying things like "I'm fine with those trans people but the cyborgs is just too far!" in like ten years or whatever. "There are no countries only economy zones with magic soil" kinda thought
Sorry to go all “X” on you specifically, I’ve been REALLY, REALLY good about not doing that. I’ll take my “Election Day” gimme. Nothing personal.
I hear you, and honestly, I agree with almost everything you just said. You are 100% right that the uniparty is a machine that only moves in one direction. The Left builds the leviathan, and the Right manages it and tells us to be grateful. You are right that waiting for a politician to save us is a trap, and that men need to be building parallel institutions instead of begging the manager to run the prison better. But you asked where it says a certain amount of people can change it. Let me show you. It's in Article V of the Constitution. It states that if two-thirds of the state legislatures (34 states) apply, Congress shall call a convention for proposing amendments. They wrote the override switch into the rulebook. It has never been successfully used because the uniparty fights it tooth and nail, but the mechanism is there. And Congress has abolished major agencies when forced by the people—the ICC in 1995, the INS in 2002, the Office of Thrift Supervision after 2008. It wasn't a President who did it alone; it was Congress, forced by pressure. The voting game is rigged. I agree with you completely. But the Article V game is the one they fear the most. It doesn't start with a savior in the White House. It starts with 34 states, and that starts with people waking up and demanding their state legislators actually use the rulebook they left for us. We aren't quitting the game. We are flipping the board.
I think it's even worse than that. The Right pushes to "build the wall" which will not really be used to keep people out, but rather to keep people in (North Korea style). The Right also pushes for Digital IDs for... election integrity. (If the State really wanted election integrity, mail-in ballots and electronic voting would be banned.) The Right also pushes *openly* for even more wars and blatant genocides. They don't even have the decency to be hypocrites about it. The Right also prints *bigly*, but mostly for the war machine. So the Right also pushes us into dystopia. They just go at it from a different angle. Less dick-cutting, less mandatory death shots, more digital IDs, more wars.
↑