You know what would be REALLY bad for Bitcoin? If everyone blindly trusted a centralized dev team, bent to appeals to authority and willfully ignored gigantic red flags. If no one defended Bitcoin’s core principles and ethos. That would be REALLY bad for Bitcoin. As in a death sentence for the mission of separating state and money.

Replies (37)

Bitcoin is permissionless. The protocol doesn’t care about your definition of “money.” If miners include it and users pay for it, it’s valid. Nodes choose their own policies. That’s not censorship — that’s markets. #Bitcoin isn’t a bank. It’s a neutral settlement network.
The implied meaning is stronger than “just filters.” It’s about who gets to decide what Bitcoin is for. Filters are coded by a gatekeeper.
SatsAndSports's avatar
SatsAndSports 9 months ago
I made this chart on why BIP110 is anti-bitcoin. "Spam" was never the debate The rest of us care about scaling bitcoin, and we are very successful at ensuring that the UTXO set is kept small, and ensuring big miners don't benefit from out-of-band systems Knots/BIP110 is an attack on Bitcoin. But it's also now a boring distraction, and therefore we'll see more blocks signal for BIP54-Consensus-Cleanup than we do for BIP-110 satsandsports.github.io/BIP110/
So you gonna take on one of these fork futures offers, or just shitpost about things you don’t understand for clout?
Every individual has to make a moral choice. It’s an obligation. If enough people make the right choice everything will be fine. I chose #bitcoin to be money. And I chose #Bip110. You don’t tell me what to do.
21seasons's avatar
21seasons 9 months ago
We use all kinds of filters for all kinds of spam. Has spam massively reduced anywhere?
Oh the "you are not technical enough to understand the brillians of core devs" There are a billion technically right decisions that can be made for the direction of Bitcoin. What hodlnaut is arguing is that core are plotting a wrong path. This requires no technical insight to debate.
Spam came with the inscriptions exploit which the compromised Core devs refused to fix. Before that filters work and transactions were monetary as it can be seen. Now we have the Core V30 from the compromised Core devs that is an attack on Bitcoin. BIP110 fixes it. image
No, I’m not on v30 and I hate junk as much as you do. But don’t kid yourself: v30 is policy, not God’s law — yet letting a self-anointed “legit use-case” committee set defaults can drift into soft censorship. Maybe next illicit use-case would be using Bitcoin for gambling? We have a precedent here. Core v30 raised OP_RETURN policy to 100k + multiples by default; you can still clamp it back to 83. The real monster is centralizing out-of-band miner pipelines if you try to shun demand at relay level.
21seasons's avatar
21seasons 9 months ago
Haven't there been spam on Bitcoin since it's creation? Satoshi "spammed" message in block 1, colored coins and NFT have been thing since 2012 etc.
21seasons's avatar
21seasons 9 months ago
BIP110 doesn't actually fix anything. It just tries to prevent some people from transacting, even though they're willing to pay the fee. That itself sounds quite backwards thinking, shouldn't we try to build system that would have less discrimination on who/why/when transactions are happening 🤔
Not 40% of the transactions. Calling " Satoshi "spammed" message in block 1" is stupid. By default Bitcoin Knots allows 42 Bytes OP_RTEURNs and that is fine, a sane default but also gives people the freedom to set whatever they want.
BIP110 fixes the abuse of spam. And of course that spammers and scammers would defend inscriptions, ordinals, NFTs and other scams. They are against BIP110. Bitcoin is Freedom Money and BIP110 helps exactly that. image
21seasons's avatar
21seasons 9 months ago
"sane default but also gives people the freedom to set whatever they want" This is good that people can choose, even though it's quite meaningless setting. There's much more interesting things to look at and configure in bitcoin config, so by default it would be best that there's no limit and if somebody wants to setup some filters for some reason and knows what they're doing, they should be free to do it.
Wrong. OP_RETURN filter at 42 Bytes is good as it keeps peoples own mempool free of spam and those people don't relay spam on Bitcoin Monetary Network.
21seasons's avatar
21seasons 9 months ago
I think it's somewhat contradicting to say that Bitcoin is freedom money while promoting a change that tries to prevent people from sending valid transactions.
It is not contradictory because Bitcoin is permissionless Monetary Network and no one is preventing people from sending and recieving monetary transactions and that is now proven with real world transactions. Spam abuses Bitcoin and needs to be filtered out.
21seasons's avatar
21seasons 9 months ago
But you cannot say what transactions every people consider spam. That's why it would be best to include all valid tx's and if wanted, then one can fine tune.
Akashi Hyogo's avatar
Akashi Hyogo 9 months ago
This is what happens when we fight for scraps. I was hoping bull market + increase in transaction volumes would take us out of this madness. Instead we are heading for a brutal bear market with contentious fork -> chain and community split -> even more drama and selling.
And it all started with the compromised Core devs releasing Core V30 At that point we didn't even know about their meetings with Epstein and Epstein investing in them ... image
all these current conflicts are downstream of the blocksize war. the blind trust started then and we should've had two blocksize increases since.
You can unfortunately use is as a data base duev to core not implementing Lukes patch to to the Taproot bug. I hope this will change
Jose Sammut's avatar
Jose Sammut 5 months ago
The disagreement is healthy. I don't even know what side he's on, but he's right here whichever way. Some of you are the problem.
↑