Scoundrel's avatar
Scoundrel 7 months ago
You should think for yourself. I respect you a lot more than @Super Testnet at this moment in time. To be honest, it feels like you are degrading your position by focusing your attention on the privacy of the protocol. Tell me, would lightning be a trash and pointless currency if Monero was a good privacy technology? To me it seems like most people like lightning for other reasons. What about you? Is privacy the only real special feature of lightning in your eyes?

Replies (2)

with Catallax, I am primarily focusing on decentralization and an open protocol for this kind of bounty work. All the other options are centralized platforms (lightning bounties, etc.). Nostr zaps are an extremely ergonomic solution that allows this protocol to be simple while still somewhat strong on privacy and easy to implement for a wide range of users. I am attempting to author a simple, base protocol that _others_ will extend for their own purposes. If someone wants to use the Catallax event Kinds but use Monero for payment, I'm happy for them! Ideally, the protocol wouldn't bake-in lightning or any other payment approach. as long as a payment receipt can be proven in the event, that's all that's required. Once I finish the first reference implementation I will have to take a look at loosening the lightning integration (if appropriate/possible), but for now it seems like the most friction-free path forward to get something in to the world.
Scoundrel's avatar
Scoundrel 7 months ago
Fair enough. However since it seems to me that you have put a lot of genuine thought and good effort into your project, I feel obligated to tell you that I don't see the point. Darknet marketplaces and crypto invoice services already do a lot of work to enable secure and anonymous commerce, and I can't see how Nostr would enable anything better. In fact, every single Nostr project I've seen so far suffers from the same fundamental flaw. Nostr is a solution looking for a problem, and none of the people developing for Nostr actually have a problem they need Nostr to solve. It's bizarre to me. It all seems so disengenuous and artificial. I just want to understand why people are trying so hard. Is everybody here a scounrel who has been kicked out of 109 communities and they had no choice but to find one where they control their own account? The only hypothesis that makes sense to me is that they are all people trying to earn money without creating value by artificially inflating how popular and useful Bitcoin appears with a million useless little projects using it. That would explain a lot, but I think my time is better spent trying to find alternative explanations. Do you have any insight?