Some honest talk about the BCH ecosystem on Nostr: The vast majority of content on BCHNostr is pure spam and garbage. Repetitive, valueless memes, fake giveaways, bots reposting, and endless, hollow complaints. It’s sad to see that what should be a space for building and discussing Bitcoin Cash has turned into a noisy timeline that drives away serious people. And if we look at topic.cash, things don't get much better: most "topics" are irrelevant, outdated, or of absolutely no interest to anyone who actually wants to see progress in BCH. We need more signal and far less noise. Who else is tired of all this empty content? I get that people want to earn sats, but it lacks authenticity. If you want to keep posting trash, go to Facebook, X, or other networks that specialize in that sort of thing. image

Replies (5)

I understand the frustration, and I agree that quality matters. But I also believe the BCH ecosystem grows when we encourage people to improve rather than simply push them away. More meaningful discussions, useful content, genuine experiences, and constructive feedback can help create the signal we all want to see. There is definitely room for improvement, but building a stronger community is something we can all contribute to. 💚
I don't think “GTFO” is the answer. Maybe the incentives aren't properly aligned to promote quality content, or maybe it's just a matter of time. Shitposters will eventually get bored if no one pays attention to them. From my perspective, the platform needs to mature to the point where people stop talking about the platform itself and start discussing other topics. But that’s a matter of time; for example, posts on Instagram aren’t about Instagram, because enough time has passed for people to start talking about other things. On Mastodon, people used to spend all their time talking about Mastodon and how it was better than the alternatives. After years, people started discussing a variety of topics, including personal ones. But it didn’t happen overnight. Maybe I’m wrong, but the site’s very name, “BCHNostr,” might be contributing to it being somewhat single-topic (BCH and Nostr), though I’m not sure if the name has that kind of influence.
Has anyone been able to convince people on the Telegram Bitcoin Cash (BCH) group to join a Marmot Protocol Nostr group so they're not dependent on a centralized app for communication? There are lots of great things shared there. Even if mainstream & public BCHNostr has a lot of spam, a Marmot group would allow for moderation & those of us who are here to see BCH adoption grow & the BCH protocol improve to have a nice, decentralized way to chat.