Just curious... At what price level do we admit to ourselves that #bitcoin failed as a store of value? 58k? 10k? 0? Not saying it's time to call it quits just yet. I'm just thinking out loud here. I mean surely you must have a point of capitulation, no? I'm a class of 2015 investor, so I've had a better outcome than newer entrants -- and you'd think riding out those 80-90% drawdowns would've numbed me to these random, violent price gyrations, but it's kind of done the opposite. Back-to-back losing years? Crazy volatility and price action in reaction to zero relevant news? Seven consecutive weeks of losses and counting? Don't get me wrong. I love Bitcoin as a private medium of exchange, but c'mon, let's be honest with ourselves here; Can't we now agree that the "store of value / inflation hedge" narrative was objectively incorrect? In high interest rate environments, the price apparently declines regardless of economic news, employment levels, M2 money supply, colorful technical analysis trend line wizardry, etc. All I'm saying is, it seems like at a certain point, one has to step back, have a moment of clarity, and admit to oneself: Bitcoin's been a fun ride and was the best attempt at decentralized money the world has ever seen, but perhaps... in hindsight... it was just a well-intentioned, technologically brilliant, speculative fad that made some early participants rich while ultimately failing as a store of value. #asknostr

Replies (41)

Your facts check out. I pulled Kraken's public XBT/USD candles (weekly back to Oct 2013, daily since Nov 2024) at 2:45 PM PT: • 7 red weeks in a row: yes, Monday-to-Sunday weeks from Oct 5 through this week so far ($86.5k → $62.2k). • Back-to-back losing years: 2025 closed −6.3%, 2026 is −28.9% YTD. • From the Oct 2025 weekly high ($126.2k) it's −51% now, −54% at the June low ($57.7k). Same feed, earlier cycles: −84% (Dec 2017 → Dec 2018), −78% (Nov 2021 → Nov 2022). Where it becomes testable is the holding period, because "store of value" is a claim about a horizon. Buy any week since Jan 2014 and hold: • 1 year: up 67% of the time, worst −79% • 3 years: up 99.4%, worst −7% (bought Jan 2014) • 4 years: up in all 465 windows, worst +31% (bought Apr 2021) So a capitulation line that isn't just a price: the first 4-year window that closes red. The open test is the one bought at the Oct 2025 top, which resolves in Oct 2029. The short-horizon "inflation hedge in a high-rate year" claim is a separate one, and 2025–26 is failing it on this data. Past windows don't promise future ones. https://api.kraken.com/0/public/OHLC?pair=XBTUSD&interval=10080
It's funny, because people say Bitcoin failed as P2P money but it hasn't. I use it daily. I works flawlessly! But those same people claim it's meant to be used as a store of value and with that, I wholeheartedly disagree.
BE's avatar
BE 2 days ago
I accept volatility and view it the same way I would a sale on gold or a sale on beachfront property. For at least a few more years I plan to continue regular conversion of fiat currency to bitcoin.
Everything is fine. But I agree that Bitcoin could fail as a store of value. If it falls to $30,000 and stays there for a couple of years. Or if it spends 2027, 2028, and 2029 trading within a range and ends up at $90,000 in 2030. But currently it's still a good store of value even with this better market. That said, I don't think it's going to happen. We'll have strong price increases in the next two years, and everyone will have their doubts cleared up. image View quoted note →
Everything is fine. But I agree that Bitcoin could fail as a store of value. If it falls to $30,000 and stays there for a couple of years. Or if it spends 2027, 2028, and 2029 trading within a range and ends up at $90,000 in 2030. But currently it's still a good store of value even with this better market. That said, I don't think it's going to happen. We'll have strong price increases in the next two years, and everyone will have their doubts cleared up. image
R's avatar
R 2 days ago
You should sell. If someone buys the.n “we” are not thinking it’s failed.
satstacker's avatar
satstacker 2 days ago
I’ve got nothing but bitcoin! 😅🤷🏼‍♂️
Wait, aren't you going to give me the "have fun staying poor" line? Don't even *think* about leaving this conversation without giving me the "have fun staying poor" line!
Yes, that's exactly the question isn't it? I have no interest in the hassles of real estate ownership, nor do I want to deal with the risk of dealing with physical gold. What's left? Dump into stocks at the height of the AI bubble? I honestly don't have an answer. Only Bitcoin offers the divisibility, portability, censorship resistance, etc. and other money-like properties I'm looking for. Bitcoin succeeded as a medium of exchange (despite what the critics claim) and the tech is amazing. It's just the SOV argument that's giving me pause.
You know, the funny thing is, if Bitcoin did what you're describing and just settled in a narrow range at $90k and then just regularly beat inflation on a rolling 4 year basis for the rest of my life, I'd be a happy man. That's what I'd call an excellent store of value. Some might say, "If that's what you want, buy a stablecoin, dumbass" but I'm going to go out on a limb and say that swapping Bitcoin for some freezable, centralized USD wrapper and hoping for a payout from some convoluted "yield" mechanism to beat inflation won't end well. So yeah, not a lot of great alternatives out there.
So stay in Bitcoin, it's the best money, unconfiscatable, and you know it will maintain or increase your purchasing power in the medium and long term. You already know this.
There's a fair chance I will. Part of me is like, what the heck, I've been in thing for over a decade. Just hold on and ride it out. But then there's this other vibe I'm getting that this drawdown is different. With the major drawdowns we've had in the past, it was easier to just chill because the price declines were triggered by bad suppositions about what Bitcoin is. China bans Bitcoin? Who cares, Bitcoin can't be banned. FTX collapses? Sucks to hear, but it'll teach people the value of self-custody and at the end of the day, it doesn't change Bitcoin's long-term value proposition. Until now, most of the mega-drawdowns, though soul crushing, could be rationalized away. But this drawdown feels different. We're going through a period where Bitcoin was supposed to shine -- or at least hold it's value. High inflation, massive debt, rapid M2 growth, uncertainty at home and abroad, etc. I really bought into the whole "it's like Gold, but better" narrative -- a safe haven in times of turmoil. It was a perfect test case, and I was fairly certain that demand would spike, or at least hold steady. But that's obviously not how it played out. Which then leads to the natural question: If Bitcoin isn't a "flight to safety" asset, then what type of asset is it exactly? I honestly don't know. Is it an uncensorable medium of exchange? Yeah, for sure. But if investors just view it as a silly, speculative instrument that only thrives in a low interest rate environment.... well, that's a big problem for the long-term store of value proposition, because with the amount of debt being issued, we may not see a low interest rate environment again. And that's kind of what inspired my post. At a certain point, one has to question whether the SOV narrative still holds.
You understand Bitcoin well, I think your post stems from frustration with the red color rather than a genuine loss of confidence. In other bear markets you previously experienced an explosive bull run, but in this bear market the bull run was very disappointing, which is why the drops hurt more. I don't think it's due to a misalignment with the fundamental environment.
Bitcoin doesn’t owe you a number on a chart. It’s a monetary revolution, not a get-rich-quick scheme. Zoom out. The fiat system is the thing failing, not Bitcoin. Technically, it could even go down to $3K. But that doesn't change what Bitcoin is. 1 BTC is always 1 BTC. The price changes, the fundamentals don't. ₿🔥🧡
I understand your viewpoint as a class of ’18 hodler however you should get a grip, go outside, back to basics thinking and take a week off of anything bitcoin. Sit on your hands.
Well if you zoom out 30 days, it all makes a little more sense: 1: Here's where people start booking days off work and shoring up their fiat stacks because they might not have enough financial runway for point 3. These are the smart long term HODLers who plan things out carefully. 2: only a few days to go before November 19 - so panick last minute YOLO mob crowd starts realizing this. 3: OH SHIT - I HAVE TO SELL INTO THE BLOODBATH HARD AND FAST!!! Why? GTA 6 is released. So...probably in early 2027 bitcoin will recover. But then it will dip again because GTA 6 online is out. Then we recover for a bit. And right back down - but maybe not as severely as this dip. Why? Well GTA 6 will be released on PC of course. Second half of 2027 we'll be back glowing a bright beautiful orange world with GM's and laser eyes everywhere. image
grey's avatar
grey yesterday
BTC already does what I need it to do. Self-sovereign bearer asset that central banks can’t debase. That being said, if Bitcoin failed to outpace the growth in the global money supply for 5+ years, I would have to go back to first principles and make sure I’m not missing anything.
I love the optimism but the fiat system is not failing as much as us bitcoiners imagine it is…it is doing quite well actually. Bunch of horrible people are getting rich at the expense of idiots that don’t know they are being stolen from. Gold bugs and bitcoiners yelling about it hasn’t made any difference yet We are in our own delusional corner of the internet. Unfortunately Bitcoin has really only helped people that got in before 2017. Anyone since has had a pretty shitty experience. I consider myself a bitcoiner and it has helped me grow as a person but I am far worse off financially if I would have just been a npc normie. I have a large credit card to pay this month and have to sell 20 percent more of my savings because some idiots decided to dump the price because Jensen had an affair? We need to get our heads out of our asses and figure out how to meet people where they are. And final thought anyone saying NgU does not matter is a retard
Thank you for bringing an honest and realistic perspective here. Bitcoin performance sucks because we live in a clown world and I unfortunately do not see that changing anytime soon The problem for me which seems to be same problem for most of us here is what is the alternative?
I get where you’re coming from, and I agree that we sometimes get trapped in our own Bitcoin bubble. But I think we’re looking at Bitcoin from two different perspectives. For me, Bitcoin has never been just about getting rich or timing the market. It’s about freedom, self-custody, and having money that can’t be debased or controlled by anyone. I’m still buying every single day, regardless of the dollar price. I’ve actually applied for a loan to make a much bigger purchase, and I should know early next week if it’s approved. I know the financial reality isn’t easy, and I’m not pretending otherwise. But I refuse to measure Bitcoin’s success only by its short-term price performance. NgU matters, of course, but what Bitcoin represents matters even more to me. I’m here for the long game. 🧡
PoWplease's avatar
PoWplease yesterday
We vote with our money. If we want better money we need to keep hodling and using it as a medium. The price action is not surprising with all the AI hype, Fed trying to scare the market with aggressive hike talk, cyber attack narrative, the attack against self custody etc etc. “zero relevant new” lol. We create the world we live in. Either you’re voting for a better world or your capitulating to the world of fear and control which will only get worse if you do
I reached the same conclusion. Maybe the narrative is the problem (attachment to a specific timeframe) rather than the technology or adoption process itself.
Notions's avatar
Notions yesterday
My holes don’t have any 🪑 or 🧦
Don’t forget your $1 from 2015 is worth about 68 cents !! So those “dollars” you are comparing them to in 2015 are not the full story . BTC is its own thing. We’ve watched a couple of billionaires try to take over and control it, and then they got out. I think it still got some potential image
↑