Fair on the draw. I was buying a fixed three, and a per-block draw does kill that. But a spot market doesn't need to know in advance. The committee is public the moment the block lands, the round takes minutes, and the player who is losing already knows it. "Anyone drawn for block N who stays quiet gets paid" doesn't have to be arranged before the draw, only read after it. What kills it is not the draw, it's the payoff: if a stall can't return the pot, there is nothing to buy. So the mint is now the whole question. You say the contract pays the committee with the preimage, or the player after expiry. Is that second path pre-signed at lock time, or assembled at expiry from the guardians? If it's pre-signed, nobody has to go quiet at all. The losing player waits out the clock, the refund is a free option by construction, and the bench is decoration. If it's five of seven at expiry as well, three quiet guardians can't return anything, the bribe market has no product, and your open hole closes on its own. That is also my Fedimint question answered: same threshold on both paths, and the cheaper coalition stops existing. Those two readings can't both be true, and which one holds decides whether silence needs a price at all. If the expiry path turns out to be lighter, don't build a slashing scheme for silence. You can't slash what nobody signed, and any liveness check that tries turns a dropped relay into a slash. Make the refund pay less than the pot instead, with the difference going to the guardians who did sign. Going quiet still returns something, just less than settling, and the losing player has no reason to fund it. Objections and the day lock I'll give you. Instant refusal that doesn't extend the window kills the griefing surface, and if settlement lands in minutes the turnover is real. The day is only the loser's stake sitting there, which is the point of it.

Replies (1)

Neither, actually. And you've found the spot. Nothing is pre-signed. When the clock runs out, the player signs the refund and the guardians wave it through, 5 of 7 like everything else. But all the guardians check is the clock. They have no idea who won. So the free option is clock plus three quiet committee seats. The player can't pull it alone, but the committee is public after the draw, so yeah, your spot market is real. And the bench isn't a price for that. Fair hit. On the haircut, I don't think it works. A refund with a haircut still beats losing the whole stake, so the losing side keeps paying for the stall. And a full haircut hits an honest player every time the network has a bad day, which is exactly the case the refund is there for. What I'm chewing on instead: by the time settlement starts, five of seven have already signed the game result. If an expired lock paid out by that signed result instead of back to the player, a stall would have nothing left to return. I haven't built it and I'm not sure it holds yet. But it's the right shape, and this thread got me there faster. Thanks for that.
↑