The post's central thesis is that updating your filters cannot be done in a decentralized way, and he cites adblockers as an example
This thesis is wrong and adblockers prove it. Adblockers that don't do what users want are ignored and their usage quickly drops to nil
His post also contains several other blunders, like "The goal of this change is not to help transactions to slip through more easily" -- it literally is. The motivation for the change is to invite spammers to use op_returns. Most of whom explicitly say they don't want to use op_returns.
He also presents a false dichotomy at the end of the post, asking why his opponents even care about bitcoin if they think spam can kill it. As if somehow the people who welcome spam care about bitcoin and the people who fight it don't. You can like bitcoin *and* fight spam on it via filters.
Login to reply
Replies (6)
this thread is gonna be a great example of your thesis here
Part of the reason why the Core side is a loser in the spam debate is that they generally prefer arguing from feelings and emotion, whereas the Knots side relies more on technical arguments
View quoted note →
View quoted note →
look
we know you belong to the "just say anything, even if doesn't make total sense" school of debate
but just to be clear
you think this sort of arrangement,
where there are dozens (maybe hundreds?) of different centralized authorities with custom filters and users can pick and choose what txs their mempool sees,
thats the preferred design?
I don't know what you mean by centralized authorities with custom filters
do you think everyone who writes a piece of software is a central authority? if someone makes a thing and puts it online for free, and users say "hey, that does a thing I want, I will run that" or "nah, I don't like it, I won't run it" <-- there's no central authority involved
ok. that's one.
after three I'm not engaging with your disingenuous bullshit anymore.
the end user isnt figuring out what the necessary parameters are to filter.
they are getting them from somewhere and calle is totally correct they must be updated regularly to be effective.
your meme is propaganda trash for that reason alone.
> the end user isnt figuring out what the necessary parameters are to filter
Wow, you sure know a lot about people you don't know
> they are getting them from somewhere and calle is totally correct they must be updated regularly
Calle said they must be updated "every single day" AND users have to download them daily. And this is an obviously absurd position, do you have to download adblock every single day? No, only when it stops working.
Totally on point. Core Devs have a superiority complex, what other person behaves in such a way about their jobs?
When Core Devs have this opinion of their users, their ego must be totally ruling their minds, hence all the emotional illogical fallacies in their arguments.
When Core Devs have this opinion of their users, their ego must be totally ruling their minds, hence all the emotional illogical fallacies in their arguments.