Why not? The reaction helps people using clients that don't support NIP-56 Reports (which is almost all of them) to know that the post is not good.

Because 1. It counts as engaging with the post which is not the intent ( I almost never give a negative reaction. If I don't like something I just ignore it ) 2. There are clients that show the List of Likes/Reactions and these posts pop-up if Mute Lists are not used & pollute that page. And like you yourself mentioned, what counts as a positive & negative reaction itself is a flexible contextual thing...eg.I use 😱 emoji, mostly as a faux-shock & never negatively. So I am not sure it's useful to add reaction of any sort, especially if I can't undo it. Would appreciate if you could reconsider.

gm, be sure to check out great conversation between @சாரு-秋陽 & @Vitor Pamplona on spam and reports View quoted note →

Context:

Just another frustrated user left in the dust Try another client is my suggestion

Haha 😅 I love Amethyst 💜 And Vitor does make changes based on user feedback -I remember he even did a translation UX overhaul after some users complained. So hoping for the best 🤞