Honestly, I’m not sure I want Nostr or relays to keep all my notes and media forever. Who’s going to read my notes from three years ago? I’m not even interested in them anymore. And if half the relays and media servers I used back then are gone in ten years, who cares?
My views change fundamentally every ten years. If they didn’t, I wouldn’t be growing as a person. What I posted in the past might not reflect how I think or feel today. My opinions, my interests, even my sense of humor and what I find funny can all change. Do every stage of our lives really need to be preserved forever for everyone to see? I’m the most current version of myself today.
That’s why the right to be forgotten matters so much. Don’t hold me responsible for something I posted ten years ago. I probably see it differently now, or I might not even care about the subject anymore. A chronological timeline captures moments in time, but it doesn’t define who I am now. What matters is today, not tomorrow or yesterday.
Login to reply
Replies (51)
Idk maybe it'll normalize people changing their views
i still can't wrap my head around this "right to be forgotten" thing as it seems to imply control over anothers memory which seems unjust to me.
No, not about someone elses memory but the media the information is stored in
that's still exerting control over someone else's physical property, is it not? seems like a violation of property rights.
Which is more valuable, the information or the medium it’s stored on?
idk, i'm clearly libertarian on this and would rather leave the value assignment along with the right up to the discression of individuals rather than constrain it to a universal principle.
But you do realize that views that seem harmless and legitimate today could be used against you tomorrow if the regime changes and the political climate shifts.
i think that is inevitable.
Therefor => right to be forgotten
yeah, i'm still seeing the logical flow


You can be fairly sure your own rig has forgotten.
Your government can mandate that Google forget.
You can't ever be sure that the NSA, me, and Sumedh the Spambot-master have forgotten.
And you certainly can't be sure the ex-friend who was watching you type in meatspace has forgotten.
Public keys, politicians and diapers need regular changing, its just the way things are.
I don't see how you can call it a right. You can say you appreciate being forgotten but calling it a right implies that someone is oppressing you by retaining information that you put out.
Bazinga 😅
I didn’t make up the term, and it’s part of privacy.
Right to be forgotten - Wikipedia
What does that mean?
Sir it’s time to watch the Big Bang Theory show
Yeah it's a positive right, not a negative right. It's invoked the same way they invoke shit like "right to housing". It is a restriction on others speech reframed as a right and if you read that article you'll see that the legal application of it is rather arbitrary.
You can make a limited case for it based on Islamic ethics and morality due to the prohibition on backbiting and publicizing others' sins, but invoking a blanket right over information about yourself and demanding it have an arbitrary expiry date is far from that.
Look at it this way: We talk a lot about sovereignty and owning our own data. That also means being able to delete and overwrite it, and Nostr is particularly bad at that.
correct. i too fail to see the oppression angle
sorry it's just a joke
The internet is written by pen, not pencil. This “right to be forgotten” thing is mostly a fake solution for the made up problem of witch hunting/cancel culture.
Fake because it doesn’t address your adversary making archived copies of what you said, especially in nostr where your notes are signed by your nsec (and thus can have their authenticity proven even after all relays go down).
Honestly I would much prefer if society grew less hypocritical and more empathetic, the same way I would prefer for either bitcoin or monero to take over fiat so… yeah.
Maybe consider using to a pseudonym or switching a platform with plausible deniability?
Yeah. You own your data by storing it. You don't own data that other people store. When someone publishes a note for the whole world to see, and you download it, that is your data. It's your data belonging to you, even if it's from and about them. They don't have a right to come to you and demand you delete something off your hard drive. Data sovereignty is about not giving your data away in the first place, precisely because you can't naively expect them to delete it when you ask them to.
Data gets lost through apathy. It is fundamentally backwards to expect to live in a paradigm where you take positive action and expect data to be gone. Its only possible if everyone involved is a good faith actor.
Just imagine you shit yourself in school in front of 1 person. You can ask them to not tell anyone, and if they are are a good person, that secret might die there. But if you shit yourself in front of the whole class, theres no way in hell it's not making its way around the whole school. If a year later you invoke your right to privacy every time it's mentioned, your only guaranteeing it will never be forgotten. Your best bet is to just ignore it and let people get tired of sharing it and then people will start to forget it.
You know this is true, because even the people who won their privacy lawsuit in the wiki article, they are more famous than they would've been otherwise. We only know Gabrielle Melvin was a whore because she sued them for exposing her past. If she didn't, we would never know.
Yeah, but if I step away to use the bathroom and leave my computer on for a minute, and my son takes the chance to post “my dad shit himself” for the whole world to see, I should be able to delete it. But deleting things on Nostr is tricky. That’s why I don’t mind if relays don’t last forever. Why are you making such a big deal out of it?
Welp, my notes are mostly for fun and nothing really deep or meaningful, so yeah, in 10 years they aren't very valuable but I do look back at some of them and smile or laugh. I'm my own best audience, after all.
Good for you anon
Yes, it would be nice if they let you delete it. But you don't have a right to force them to.
NIP-40 solves this but only if the relays respect it. Hard to tell all of them are, but it's the best option we've got so far.
This note will expire in 14 days if all goes by the plan.
Ok, I worded the first sentence in a confusing way:
“Honestly, I’m not sure I want Nostr or relays to keep all my notes and media forever.”
I didn’t mean that I don’t want relays to store my events forever. I meant that I don’t really care if relays go down and my old notes disappear, or if relays occasionally clear out old data to free up space. I wanted to say, I’m not particularly interested in measures to preserve my events for as long as possible.
I didn’t mean, as some people here are putting words in my mouth, that I want to force relay operators to delete my events.
So is the human brain.
I have a human right to trepan people until they forget I once wore white socks with black trousers, but they keep running away...
correct but if i'm publishing something to someone else's relay then that data is no longer my exclusive property because i have entrusted another to manage distribution. how is this an issue of privacy?
Agreed. I spent a zillion minutes getting hand cramps scrolling back to my first posts on #nostr nearly 3 years ago. Firstly, the embarrassment and humiliation of my ignorance at the time gave the distinct sensation of having bathed in boiling oil. Secondly, as you say, growth involves movement, change is part of the equation, and it felt slightly self-indulgent to spend the time and effort just so I could congratulate myself for how far I’ve migrated from my foolish former incarnation. Thirdly, who gives a rip besides me anyway?
that proves you’re still young.
You have no idea
My police is that all notes deletes and not keep after 3 month . That also prevent from bulk load .
Let’s make new NIP : the right to be forgotten . It’s also served freedom of speech at its finest .
Nah


No. That’s a narrow view, even from a libertarian perspective. Self ownership includes having a say in how your identity is defined. I’m not the same person I was ten years ago. If an archive permanently and prominently links something I said back then to who I am today, it assigns me an identity I may have moved on from. No operator or relay provider has the right to freeze my opinion in time indefinitely. What if I only agreed to something for a limited time, but the relays didn’t let me set that kind of term in the agreement?
Before the internet, forgetting was the default. Memories faded, documents got lost, and so on. Forgetting was never a privilege. It was simply a normal part of social life. So the right to be forgotten doesn’t invent anything new. It just restores the status quo we had before. Citizens whose every action can be traced forever are a tool for concentrating power, no matter who holds it. Anyone who can track everyone for decades and bring up things they said years ago has leverage over you. That’s not a free society. It’s a digital glass house. A world where no mistake or out of context remark ever disappears should be a nightmare for everyone.
You say you’re a libertarian. A free market depends on being able to leave. A market you can’t exit, including when it comes to your data, isn’t a market. It’s a trap. Networks that make deletion difficult create exactly that kind of trap. It’s like living in a city you’re not allowed to move away from.
It’s really hot subject about liberty and freedom
Between centralized and decentralized .
we can erase our self from Google or search engine by limiting or erase our account .
In Nostr , it live forever . To the admin of relay . If delayed in one relay , it still be alive and flung in some other relay .
The right to be forgotten is actually made multi signature with Frosstr or igloo server ( shared identity ) is seems less importance .
Man doesn’t need to worry about key signature as man can use his right to be forgotten ?? Interesting subject ! I might be think about it this all day .
i wasn't saying i'm a libertarian. idk what the libertarian perspective on this even is. i just know it doesn't resonate with.
forgetfulness is a human trait. that doesn't make it something we should pursue as a right. i think memory is a much higher value and believe it should be encouaged. that's what i think is where liberation lies.
I’ve heard of it. It’s a sitcom, right?
In life , people always changed . Some have repentances and some turn
Into oblivion , God give us blessing on old age to become dement so that we can forget our bad deeds In the past .
I think all notes should be able to delete forever or right to be forgotten , that giving less power for some people to act like GOD by turning someone history into future control .
A friend of my father's at age 18 rolled his car in front of his local pub. And he was teased about this until the day he died, in his 70s.
Small communities always had this problem, for all of human history. People thought their own thoughts, had disapproved love affairs, and practised religion in unapproved ways, but they had to build OPSEC skills to get away with it.
Urbanisation outpaced memory for a couple of generations, but now memory has caught up. This will sound harsh, but people who want the "Right To Be Forgotten" are actually asking for society to do their OPSEC for them, instead of building the skills to "get gud".
And society can never be trusted to *actually* do that. Never.
Owning your data means the freedom to practise OPSEC yourself, and control who you share what with, under which identity, and by what channel.
I agree, and It is kind of builtin already many relays disappear
lots of notes are just test, throw away messages, ideas
There's value in understanding what influences our views in a given moment, and how they change over time. IMO, this is the real value of the chronological timeline.
I get it, people change and that's a good thing. But on Nostr nobody can really promise you'll be forgotten, anyone can keep a copy. Maybe it's better to just own the old stuff and say you see it differently now. That shows growth more than deleting it.
I understand what you mean, and in normal situations it’s not really a problem. But I’m talking about more dangerous situations, like regime changes, Orwellian thought police, or people being prosecuted for expressing their opinions. Just look at what’s happening in the UK right now, or at past regimes. I mean situations where you can no longer count on free speech being protected. We can't take the status quo for granted, things could change drastically.
Fair point, and that's where it gets scary. But in that case deleting won't really save you, they'll have scraped everything long before. The real protection is keeping your npub separate from your real name. That's something Nostr actually lets us do.
True, even your writing style can give you away. Thanks for the good chat alp, it really made me think.
Thanks for the kind words, but I really don’t think I’m that important pr influential.
better to have the twitter scrapers save your tweets forever #maketwittergreatagain