Karadenizli's avatar
Karadenizli 1 week ago
Yeah. You own your data by storing it. You don't own data that other people store. When someone publishes a note for the whole world to see, and you download it, that is your data. It's your data belonging to you, even if it's from and about them. They don't have a right to come to you and demand you delete something off your hard drive. Data sovereignty is about not giving your data away in the first place, precisely because you can't naively expect them to delete it when you ask them to. Data gets lost through apathy. It is fundamentally backwards to expect to live in a paradigm where you take positive action and expect data to be gone. Its only possible if everyone involved is a good faith actor. Just imagine you shit yourself in school in front of 1 person. You can ask them to not tell anyone, and if they are are a good person, that secret might die there. But if you shit yourself in front of the whole class, theres no way in hell it's not making its way around the whole school. If a year later you invoke your right to privacy every time it's mentioned, your only guaranteeing it will never be forgotten. Your best bet is to just ignore it and let people get tired of sharing it and then people will start to forget it. You know this is true, because even the people who won their privacy lawsuit in the wiki article, they are more famous than they would've been otherwise. We only know Gabrielle Melvin was a whore because she sued them for exposing her past. If she didn't, we would never know.

Replies (2)

Yeah, but if I step away to use the bathroom and leave my computer on for a minute, and my son takes the chance to post “my dad shit himself” for the whole world to see, I should be able to delete it. But deleting things on Nostr is tricky. That’s why I don’t mind if relays don’t last forever. Why are you making such a big deal out of it?
↑