The corollary is also true: Bitcoin Core having screwed up does not make a soft fork a good idea for Bitcoin. (FWIW I'm still trying to figure this whole thing out, so I'm not making any claims here except that your logic goes both ways. I see so many people assuming that since they don't like A that B is the solution.)

I think my post makes my position clear, and it's neither B nor A. Furthermore, I'm not in favor of BIP-110. That's why nobody understands me 😂