We are nearly 4 years into El Salvador’s Bitcoin experiment which seems a great time to take a big step back and evaluate how things are going
There’s been lots of talk about expectations vs reality for those that move down here and that’s a valuable conversation to have and I hope it continues. I firmly believe that El Salvador will benefit greatly if we can close that gap
I want to highlight a topic that I think is even more valuable to discuss though: censorship
Bitcoin attracts each of us for different reasons; at the very top of my list is censorship-resistance so that’s the lens from which I view things
There is a worrying trend here of a shrinking independent civil society. In recent weeks prominent critics have been arrested, dozens of journalists are now in exile and questioning the official narrative is more likely to result in name calling rather than a serious response of the issue raised
So that’s the problem—what is the solution? IMO it’s two-fold, an open discussion & education that encourages critical thought
I’d love to see the shrinking civil society in El Salvador openly discussed
El Salvador needs builders and independent thinkers—as many as possible!
Login to reply
Replies (5)
What prominent critics have been arrested? What journalists have been exiled?
Ruth Lopez is the most prominent re rnt arrest (and she is very prominent here and abroad. More here: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/mundo/articles/cvgnqmnj2j5o.amp
There are around 40 known journalists in exile now, more here: https://www.freepressunlimited.org/en/current/grave-concern-about-increasing-deterioration-press-freedom-el-salvador
With respect I think you are conflating two separate things. Bitcoin is only about censorship resistant money (transactions). Free Speech might encompass this, depending on your definition of same, but repression of state critical speech is a different thing to repression of state independent money.
Of course you may value both and that's fine. And I make no comment here on the authoritarian crackdown you are attributing to the Salvadorian govt. Just I think one needs to remember that the censorship resistance Bitcoin gives is specific to its monetary domain. And a state might be fine with censorship resistant money while still wanting to control (political) speech and see no inconsistency or hypocrisy.
Yes, of course there are different categories of censorship, I was just saying my general opposition to censorship is one of the reasons I value Bitcoin.
We must Deploy!!!!