We should deprecate kind 1 replies and do kind 1111 comments only.
Login to reply
Replies (20)
idgi
no
dies this have anything to do with replies disappearing?
or emojis falling out of replies?
yep
We use NIP22 comments on @Zap Cooking recipes, since those arenβt intended to show up in public feed threads, but Iβm not sure I get why a kind 1 note shouldnβt also have a kind 1 reply. Wouldnβt that make reposting and quote-posting incompatible across clients?
I don't like how kind 1 is both a note and a reply
Imagine being able to remove the 100 ifs for a reply only feed
No. That's people not using outbox. Developers or end users. Most likely a relay issue.
Or...kind 5's ππ
NIP-22 already does this. It clearly says when replying to events that is not kind 1, then kind 1111 is to be used.
for what benefit?
Why
Sure why not
Lots of code/complexity to maintain it both ways. The kind 1111 way is more elegant and powerful.
Clients can begin to offer a "quiet reply" mode that uses NIP-22.
Users can opt-in to that when they don't want their reply to show up on their feeds to everybody (and accept that at least for now it might not show up for the thread author either).
I would probably use it a lot.
I have been thinking about writing a client that would timestamp messages as sent on the current date in 2021 or something. could be fun, partitioning content by epoch. It would also screw up any idea of the authenticity of old posts
Ironic to be interjecting here, but I'd use that a lot too. I think a lot of people would.
boop beep booooop thank you but does not compute since i am a monkey.
still wondering how a damus note would get deleted when will explicitly says heβs against note deletions. and the emojis that disappear from a note β> 1) kind what? π΅
Years of old content already exists. At this point, it is set in stone.
Unlike centralized platforms there is no apply migration button
That's stupid. Nothing stops a client from generating notifications anyway.