Well, look at how Primal and Damus differ as one example. You can 100% lose posts between them if you use both.
Or, ask yourself, if Nostr were the size of X, who could afford to run a relay?
RELAYS ARE ALWAYS PERMISSIONED, THEY ARE NOT PUBLIC COMMONS
Login to reply
Replies (4)
> Well, look at how Primal and Damus differ as one example. You can 100% lose posts between them if you use both.
it depends entirely on the relay you are using and how you the client you are using implemented client-side filtering, that's not censorship...
> Or, ask yourself, if Nostr were the size of X, who could afford to run a relay?
The largest cost by far would be bandwidth, storage space is insignificant, because the likelyhood that any relay would have to store everything is essentially zero (and that's a good thing).
Thanks to @Samiz, and in the future other p2p relay protocols, many of which I assume will be integrated directly into clients (which is something I am plannign for Eve), the bandwidth cost drops as well, to the point where only small, but periodic queries would have to be performed on relays.
Also, I happen to believe that the current way messages are sent and recevied between clients and relays is straight up garbage, but by simply introducing binary messsaging, and possibly compression, we can reduce the amount of data sent and received significantly.
> RELAYS ARE ALWAYS PERMISSIONED, THEY ARE NOT PUBLIC COMMONS
that's a non-refutable and entirely definition based argument that has nothing to do with the discussion at hand. fine relays are permissioned by your definition, doesn't change my argument
This is a study of nostr resilience and how notes survive even if top 5% relays go down
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05709.pdf
Yes primal can censor me, and when they do I'll just stop using primal.
That's the thing a about nostr, it's not owned by primal and damus.
Primal and damus are just clients used to access the protocol.
If I really want to avoid being censored I can even build my own relay with my own personal media hosting.
I'm struggling to see how that's the same as any centralised social media platform.
When Facebook banned me my account was removed you can't even find it anymore, all the information censored and hidden.
Nobody has that kind of power over nostr
Didn't see this paper before! Nice find