@Max reading chapter 4 of Praxaeology of Privacy, and fine the Hoppean order intriguing. Especially in that it derives ought from those willing to engage in argument, but being silent on those who don't.
I've done a fair bit of reading on germanic paganism (as you're European, perhaps known more as Ásatrú or simply Forn Siđr, rather than Heathenry as it is often referred over here). A concept central to the ethics, at least in a reconstructionist approach, is the separation of innangarđs and útangarđs, or 'inside the fence' and 'outside the fence.' Probably silly to explain to a German speaker but it may at least share my understanding.
It occurs to me that it's always been a sticking point for me when it comes to the NAP. at the end of the day, while in broad society, 'might makes right' can make life very complicated, there are circumstances where one, or their group, may stand to objectively gain with little fear of reprisal -- either because they can annihilate or otherwise withstand retribution, or perhaps otherwise avoid revenge, be it through trickery or simply by escaping.
Of course there are plenty of reasons you can't have a society that maintains order with this as the norm -- and even if you could achieve a stasis, the resources expended looking over your shoulder would be malinvested.
Enter the division of innangarđs and útangarđs, or, perhaps as they fit in the context of this Hoppean order, those who are not within the realm of argumentation, either by their choice or mine.
Curious if there is any case you see here for the NAP between such fellows, or if indeed the possibility of them is itself a rationale for cultivating a strong social order that will defend propery rights of its own so that mutual assistance can serve as a bulwark against those outside.
A common refrain in the sagas of the vikings is 'through law, land is built,' so I do lean to this rationale as being the most likely. It is an intriguing thing to ponder, particularly looking at the intertribal relations of the Viking Age (though also the modern one, where a failure of diplomacy breaks down into a complete lack of regard for property, because basic tenets cannot be agreed to).
Anyway just musing here and thought I'd share. Loving the book, thanks for writing it. Perhaps I'll send Herman a message too...