Incredibly eye opening history and downfall of Urbit: So much to learn from here. I could totally see Nostr going down this path if the community is careless. Nostr devs would do well to read this. Relevant quote 👇 "Privacy, which ostensibly set Urbit apart from Big Tech platforms, was a staple of their marketing rhetoric—but according to employees, the network’s actual encryption was a work-in-progress. “Sovereignty” was more of an aesthetic signal than a description of my actual relationship to my data. Urbit came to feel uncomfortably similar to the subscription-based cloud services I had previously hoped it might replace."

Replies (8)

"The network’s address space—its virtual real estate—is divided into a federated hierarchy of “planets,” “stars,” and “galaxies,” each unique according to a 28-bit identifier connected to the Ethereum blockchain. " Centralised 💩 built on top of Central Mother of all Ass-h0les...
I wonder if fiatjab or the bigger customers and relays just left, would NOSTR still stand? or it will change over time
Urbit is Curtis Yarvin’s baby. Peter Thiel gave him the money to do it and he recently returned to try to right the ship as it was going nowhere. Yarvin is like the philosopher to the PayPal mafia crew, he is worth reading. Has some sharp insights but can’t hide the fact hes a snake in the grass jew either. The irony is Yarvin was earlier outspoken against #Bitcoin, his whole thing is centralising power in a monarch leads to the best results which is why he thought it would fail and why Urbit had a centralised team with a “king” and yet it was the project which failed.. note1rvmnny5kze56927xwcd8qg8s5fmmkfqc8626hl048g65vqyr0lysym0dgq
Yeah I recently read Dark Enlightenment and some of his ideas are good, mainly the ones borrowed from libertarian thinkers, but I didn't agree with his overall monarchical framing. I didn't know he was against bitcoin at first, that's interesting. It's not a surprise that urbit was a complete failure but I think there are lessons there for us that are on nostr. Like I could see nostr suffering the same fate if we are not careful. It seems like the community focused too much on the lore of urbit but didn't both sticking the Cypherpunk principles that it was supposedly built on, and urbit seemed like it was all over the place and none of the tools worked well. It had no solid foundation to build on
Yeah nostr isn't going to be "big" in the same way that Facebook Instagram TikTok are big, and we shouldn't want that. Nostr is doing something completely different in regards to digital communication and how digital communities organize around each other. I want to be here to see where this all goes!