If you'd have written that nostr is text only then it would be text only right now. I think you're underestimating the power of founding limits and consequential social enforcement. All the limits that you did set at the start are still respected.
I'm saying it's way too complicated now. First you get DMs, and that means encryption, and that means losing your nsec becomes a bigger deal, and that means we need remote signers and bunkers, and it goes down and down in a spiral.
What was stopping DMs from appearing in nostr? If you'd have said at the start "nostr is strictly not intended for encryption or DMs" in some very clear way then there would be no encryption or DMs right now, I'm pretty sure of that.
And media, the moment you allow images and video you have CSAM obligations, and CDN serving, and centralised media hosting, and notes loading the text part and then 5 seconds later loading the image part and pushing the text part 10cm down the screen, and media rot and the whole core idea of a note being self-contained no longer applicable, and on and on.
Nothing attempted to stop media from appearing in nostr.
But if you think about it media and DMs are a kind of poison.
Login to reply
Replies (1)
I did say clearly and explicitly that Nostr shouldn't be used for DMs (I did it in the Nostr Telegram group at the time, that had like 20 people, of which maybe 5 were the only ones really interested in Nostr). Still @Ben Arc made the first Nostr client with DMs after I begged him not to.
Will this clear fact make you reconsider your position? If that isn't enough you can also take into account my twtxt example. If I make an effort I can probably come up with many other things that I think Nostr shouldn't have but that now it has standardized just because not having a standard would be worse as people would do it anyway in less interoperable ways.
I never said Nostr shouldn't have images, because that idea didn't occur to me and I don't think images hurt that much (you can always opt to not use them yourself, and not associate with people that do), but I'm sure Nostr would end up having images if it had grown to more than 40 users anyway.