Login to reply
Replies (10)
Thanks for pointing me toward Konsensus. I did reach out to the team and have since had the opportunity to explore their approach.
I appreciate the ethos behind what you're building. My interest was also in exploring whether the publication itself could put some of the book's ideas into practice — not simply using Bitcoin as a means of payment, but rethinking the economic relationship between author and publisher.
That may go beyond your current model, but I think it's an interesting conversation to have. Thanks again for the pointer.
@KompassFrei Settling royalties per sale instead of twice a year would change what an author can plan around. That is a different question from which currency pays the invoice. I'd read that book. What split would you want if it were yours?
That's an interesting point, @Johnny. I agree that how and when royalties are settled matters indeed.
What I had proposed to the publisher/distributor was something slightly different: an upfront commitment to acquire a defined number of copies at a fixed price per book.
The quantity and unit price would be agreed in advance. The purchaser would then assume the commercial risk and retain the proceeds from reselling those copies, while the author would retain the intellectual property and publishing rights, as well as the freedom to sell other copies and pursue other editions or formats.
In this arrangement, the publisher's return would depend both on the value it initially attributes to the book — reflected in the price it is willing to pay — and on the value it can subsequently create through distribution and sales.
This way, rather than dividing royalties from a common pool, each party commits to a distinct contribution and participates in the value created.
I find that a more interesting starting point than deciding on a royalty percentage. What do you think?
@KompassFrei Paying up front puts the author's money in hand before the first copy sells, and I like the publisher carrying that risk. What happens to the unsold copies if the publisher wants out?
@Johnny That's what makes the initial commitment meaningful.
Before committing to a quantity, the publisher needs to form its own assessment of the book's prospects, its potential audience and its ability to distribute it successfully.
Once acquired, the copies belong to the purchaser, along with the commercial risk attached to them. There is no buyback obligation on the author's side.
In other words, we are not trying to eliminate risk; we are trying to allocate responsibility in accordance with each party's contribution and capacity.
@KompassFrei I like the author walking away with no buyback owed, and the publisher pricing that risk up front. What size order would you expect on a first commitment?
I haven't settled on a quantity, @Johnny. But perhaps we could look at an initial commitment of 300 copies as an illustration.
In fact, I wouldn't expect any payment or royalties for those first copies. The idea would be for the publisher to finance production and distribution, retain the proceeds from their sale, and assume the associated commercial risk.
That would give the publisher an opportunity to recover its investment and establish the book in the market, while the author contributes the intellectual work without claiming an immediate financial return.
The quantity should ultimately reflect the publisher's own assessment of the opportunity and the economics of making it happen.
@KompassFrei Waiving royalties on the first 300 copies is a generous way to get a publisher to say yes. I'd want the reprint terms in writing too, so copy 301 pays you.
@Johnny, our exchange has made me put the underlying idea into a more concrete framework. Here is a short discussion paper I drafted:
https://kompass-frei.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Discussion-Paper_The-Measure-of-Value.pdf
It outlines how such an arrangement might work: an initial commitment by the publisher, a deliberate allocation of the first commercial risk, the author's retained intellectual property, and a different basis for remuneration on subsequent copies.
I've deliberately left quantities and prices open, since those should definitely emerge from the publisher's own assessment of the opportunity.
I'm sharing it here because I think the proposal deserves to be considered beyond this particular book. It might even be an interesting starting point for rethinking the economic relationship between authors and publishers. It keeps the BTC denomination for subsequent acquisitions as a substantive possibility–as the unit of account actually– which is more interesting than simply accepting Bitcoin at checkout.
@KompassFrei Glad you wrote this up. I like pricing the later copies in BTC as the unit of account, it gives a publisher something real to weigh.
