Would you say the same about Email servers if they had sovereign Identity (regardless of how is that identity sovereign)? Would you say the same about Nostr image hosting solutions? I know ActivityPub is not a perfect protocol, but just assume the identity wasn't tied to the server, would that be so bad?
Login to reply
Replies (2)
it would just be nostr with a well defined outbox model, so it wouldn’t be bad
This is a manipulatively framed question. Mastodon, today, claims to be decentralized. It explicitly says “decentralized social media platform.” In actuality, Mastodon is extremely centralized (domain names are a point of centralization, even if they didn’t intend to censor or manipulative the network social graph, the registrars and registries can do it for them) but furthermore Mastodon has explicitly used its points of centralization to harm free expression. They enforced defederation as a policy to destroy the network graph.
Mastodon and ActivityPub are chronic liars. They claim decentralization fraudulently while never having offered such. They specifically abuse the authority that they have garnered by controlling a centralized network to harm speech and human rights.