There's another angle people haven't covered on Core vs. Knots. The average tenure of a core maintainer is about 3 years. In total, they've got 19 years of collective experience as maintainers. Luke, meanwhile, has 14 years of experience maintaining Knots. Suddenly the "one guy" thing doesn't seem quite so obviously problematic, especially as experience in year 1 and experience in year 5 and experience in year n are not all created equal. That all said, the answer really is more node options. We could explore having core maintainers living in a monastery and taking an oath of poverty and undergoing extreme training to beat out of them any ego and desire to be known as having made a mark to try to shape them into perfect stewards of a system that is bigger than all of us, or we could let the market shape people with open competition. As much as the notion of Bitcoin Knights Citadeliers (Citadelars?) is an amusing image, market competition seems to be far, far more realistic. image

Replies (3)

It'd make for good sci fi if nothing else. Reminiscent of the Server Monks in Sean Kennedy's Tales From the Afternow. Server Monk's Prayer: I am a node of Server, Born of flesh and blood, But enhanced by the power of its web, I have no use for pain or fear, My scripts are a focus of my will, My strength is my knowledge, My weapons are my skills, Information is the blood of my body, I am part of the greater network, I am host to the vast data of server, My flesh is weak, But my connection is eternal, And therefore I am god. Written by: Sean Kennedy