I like the pine tar for the shower. something about it feels "extra ablative" lol. but i also get the goat milk tallow for everything else, including shaving. it's luxurious for shaving, with a proper cup and brush. i drop a chopped-off chunk in the cup and leave it in there until it's gone and reload it. to be clear, these are the only two i've tried, so i'm not sure about the others! i bet they're all excellent. I also exclusively use @SoapMiner deodorant. there is literally no other brand in my bathroom for any products except toothpaste :)