It’s a bad faith argument, not inherently a real checkmate, just one that maybe you weren’t prepared to counter. Instead, you could try a checkmate focusing on why any intervention into free markets is inherently destructive, such as: Socialism is not flawed because of incentives, but because of calculation. The reason why socialism fails, despite how much computing power or information the State has, is that without property, there’s no cost. No cost, no economic calculation. No calculation, no production.