Replies (1)

In a nutshell: Aus shit the bed on the submarine deal. The independent, crowdfunded AUKUS Public Inquiry’s Commissioners’ Report (Surrendering Australia: the AUKUS Deception), released on 4 November 2026 and led by Peter Garrett with commissioners including former ADF chief Admiral Chris Barrie, calls the $368+ billion nuclear submarine deal (Pillar 1) “the worst, riskiest and most costly defence decision ever made by an Australian government.”  Key conclusions: • Delivery timelines for Virginia-class and SSN-AUKUS boats are “most likely unachievable.” • It undermines Australian sovereignty, increases the risk of being drawn into conflict with China, and undercuts nuclear non-proliferation commitments (including long-term high-level radioactive waste storage). • No convincing strategic foundations were found after 10+ days of hearings and 1,000+ submissions; governments never properly explained or scrutinised the deal. Main recommendations include immediately terminating/scrapping Pillar 1 (the submarines), suspending related base plans (e.g., near Perth), establishing a royal commission into how the deal was made, developing a proper national security strategy and cheaper submarine alternative for the Collins-class replacement, auditing costs via the ANAO, and recalibrating aspects of Pillar 2 and the China relationship.
↑