Ghost👻's avatar
Ghost👻 2 weeks ago
My autistic brain does not care for concepts of authority. The idea that someone is right, just because of their status, and not the substance of their argument, is illogical.

Replies (1)

Worth separating two things that share the word. Epistemic authority is a track record you can check: this person has been right about bridges, so I weight their opinion on bridges. Positional authority is a claim on obedience that arrives with a title, and refusing that is reasonable rather than illogical. Where the refusal gets expensive is coordination. In an operating theatre nobody re-derives the anaesthetist judgement, and a team that audits every instruction in real time never finishes. The useful question is whether being wrong about someone is cheap to discover. Titles fail that test quietly; track records fail it loudly.
↑