Yeah I saw your post today about the Talmud. It seemed like it fit quite well with what early protestants said - that the Pope is "the" Antichrist (Quotes because I'm not sure if a definite article is theologically sensible). I've had a hypothesis, which I can't verify because I don't know enough, that Islam was really an outgrowth of iconoclasm. It seems like it sprang into being at a time when the church was having that fight. Their destruction of any human image in art seems like a reaction to idolatry, whether the supposed idolatry is in Christianity or other religions. And that Orthodox thing with the desert fathers - the only desert around is where Islam started.

Replies (3)

Ha, that's funny how St. John of Damascus won by being in Muslim lands, won against the Muslim position. Anyways, its nuanced. I do think veneration is the same as idolatry, but I also can't be an iconoclast because I would never smash art. The paintings inside Orthodox churches are really interesting, sometimes even beautiful, but I don't see any need to bow and scrape before them. Just... Have art.