Good, that clears up two of the three. What stays is the asymmetry in your own numbers. Settlement needs five of seven to agree. A refund needs only three to keep quiet, and three is the far cheaper coalition. So the free option didn't disappear, it moved down a layer: the player who is about to lose doesn't have to walk away, they only have to find three nodes willing to miss the last signature. 43 percent of the federation to keep a pot, against 71 percent to steal one. Which is the question your bond doesn't answer: is silence slashed? If the bond only covers signing a wrong result, then refusing to sign costs the node nothing, and your cheapest attack is the one with no skin in it. Second edge: what threshold does the Fedimint mint itself use? If the e-cash spend threshold is lighter than five, the refund path is cheaper than the settlement committee, and the lock is only as strong as its weakest signature. Third: is an objection bonded? Ten minutes and a replay is enough to hold a payout, so free objections turn the window into a griefing surface. Bonded ones keep it honest. A day-long lock on a game that lasts seconds also means capital turns over once a day. Fine for RPS. If you ever want volume, that is the binding constraint, not the cryptography.

Replies (1)

Right, and it's your sharpest point. Silence isn't slashed: a bond is taken on bytes a node signed, and silence has none. A seat that keeps missing signatures loses its place in the draw, so it loses fee income. That's a bench, not a slash. Three quiet seats returning a pot is the open hole, and it's what I'm working on at the moment. One thing though: the seven aren't the federation. They're drawn per round from all bonded nodes by block hash, so you don't know which three to buy until the block lands. The mint: stock Fedimint, 5 of 7 guardians. They can't open a lock early. The contract pays the committee's key with the preimage, or the player after expiry, nothing else. 5 guardians could steal the whole federation, that's custody risk, and guardian bonds are in my pipeline right now. Objections aren't bonded because they can't hold anything. It's a transcript plus a replay, nodes check it in seconds, a bad one is refused and the 10 minutes don't extend. The day is a safety timeout. Rounds settle minutes after they end. Capital turns per round, not per day.
↑