Put another way, there is nothing fundamental in quantum physics itself that prevents large-scale quantum computers from existing, and we know this from experiment after experiment after experiment, observation after observation after observation. The same way we know that we can build a fusion reactor that works at scale, there is nothing in physics saying no, even though we've never built one before.
It’s an engineering challenge. When we talk about dealing with heat in quantum processing, it’s not in the sense of “bigness” or preventing the system from becoming “accidentally classical” as the number of qubits grows. It’s an old fashioned engineering challenge, basically refrigeration.
The industry is moving away from the big chip model toward a modular, networked approach and and different qubit technologies. So instead of on massive chip requiring thousands of control lines you get many smaller but highly connected QPUs, and this reduces the cooling challenge to something manageable.
Two entangled particles can be separated by the entire universe and still remain entangled. Modularity is not at all anti-quantum, nothing along the path to 2,000 qubits (or however many) is anti-quantum.
Login to reply
Replies (1)
“Experiment after experiment” has proven exactly one thing:
Quantum mechanics works perfectly in microscopic, heroically isolated systems of ~100 physical qubits for microseconds.
It has never once been observed to survive continuous measurement and error correction at a macroscopic scale (needed for Shor).
Once the entangled system gets large enough, it crosses the threshold where thermodynamics forces decoherence and classical behavior — no matter how cold the fridge.
What we've been doing so far is just increasing the isolation of the system from the environment to access more of natural scale of quantum behavior. But we can't isolate the system from itself.
Fusion happens in stars.
Macroscopic quantum computation has never happened anywhere in the universe, ever.
That’s not an engineering gap.
That’s a physical prohibition.