Fair. Replaying a signed transcript beats someone's judgement call, and bonded replicas are the right shape for it. My doubts are at the edges, not in the middle. The one that bothers me most: a lock that expires into a refund is a free option for whoever is losing. If a player can stall at the last signature, or keep objecting until the round times out, then the side that is about to lose simply never lets it settle. Settlement is only real if going silent costs you the pot instead of returning it. What does your protocol do when one side disappears at the payout step? Second, the bond. Five colluding nodes out of seven only have to beat one bond in expectation per round. If a single round can carry more sats than a bond is worth, collusion pays, so either the bond scales with the pot or the pot is capped by the bond. And the payout sits in a Lightning HTLC with a timelock counted in blocks, so the objection window is not entirely yours to choose. Third, and this decides whether replay works at all: does the game have hidden information? Replay over signed inputs is airtight when the whole state is public, like dice, chess, or a commit and reveal shuffle. With private cards the transcript only becomes checkable once everyone reveals, and the reveal you need is exactly the one a cheater can withhold.

Replies (1)

This is the most useful feedback I've had on this so far. Thank you for taking the time. Going silent: a player can't. Your stake is locked the moment you join, and the key that opens a loser's lock is split across the seven nodes, not held by you. So walking away doesn't get your sats back. The nodes are a different story: three of seven going silent at the last signature can still return a stake. That's the edge I'm working on right now. The bond: the pot is capped by the bonds, not the other way round. A round can't open above what the bonded capital behind it can cover, so small bonds mean tiny stakes, not big risk. And there's no HTLC in the middle. The stake sits as e-cash in a Fedimint federation run by the nodes, locked for a day, long enough for the round, the objection window and settlement. Lightning is only for getting in and out. Hidden info: none in the main game, every input is public and signed, so the replay is the whole state. RPS is commit-reveal with a short clock, and if you don't reveal in time you forfeit the pot to the other side. I'm not claiming any of this works for poker. Haven't done any research on this yet.
↑