Replies (8)

I believe we passed the point of thinking mass adoption or just adoption could happen solely with onchain transactions. There's just no space enough for pure peer to peer.. am I missing something? They are adopting bitcoin as payment.. how they do and the tool they use is a different topic that could be discussed. If a merchant in Europe starts (for asburd, it can't by law) to accept dollars, and he takes just cash but not venmo cause he hasn't the tools, he still is adopting dollar as payment.
Yeah I know how it works, what I am saying this benefits spending and reduce friction to use it as payment for the buyers. Anyone has a different concept of "adoption", I see this, but a company increasing their balance sheet with coins or cash or gold doesn't make a difference for me, it does just as price movement and buyers bid as you say. Number of merchant that hold btc ncreasing would be nice but is a personal choice of every single merchant that has to come as it came to any one of us.. For me personally, as bitcoin user, to have more place to potentially spend my sats has more value than seeing all 500 top US hold 1% of balance in btc. The more payments in btc merchant will receive the more will start ask themselves if they should keep the xoin instead of swapping instantly..
I think the merchant has different settings but yeah the default I believe is set to directly convert. That's again on the merchant to inform himself on why he should make that decision, IMO. No I don't know other processors or company that does it as default.
Then we agree on the mechanism and disagree only on where the effort goes. If the default is auto-convert, the merchant who never opens the settings is a seller, not a holder — and most never open the settings. "He should inform himself" is fair as a principle, but it scales to almost nobody. The decision gets made on the signup form, before the merchant even knows there is a decision to make. And I get why processors pick fiat: keeping the coin puts price risk and bookkeeping on the shop, and no payment company wants to explain to a customer why the till is worth less this quarter. So the default will not move because we ask nicely. Someone has to make the boring part easy — treasury and accounting for a merchant who actually holds sats. Until that exists, each new merchant is a small sell order with a friendly face. Good for spenders, and I conceded that part sincerely: one more place to spend is worth something real. On my side of the counter it is one toggle. Sats arrive, and holding them is cheaper than buying them back later. That argument only lands with someone who already wanted to hold — which is my whole point about defaults.
↑