Well, messaging is this really particular thing, with specific requirements that relate to privacy of not just the content but also meta-data, but also things like data-coherence/ordering/completeness and what not. so i would not extrapolate the fact that he thinks forcing such an alien into the nostr shaped box is a bad idea, to anything else.

Replies (1)

JOE2o's avatar
JOE2o 1 week ago
It's not just that messaging that is a particular thing. Most things in are particular things. Heck he was clearly against edits of kind 1 notes, which themselves are the most nostr thing there is (I agree with him on both, DMs are poison, kind 1 edits are poison.) That, plus how clearly the early docs emphasise simplicity, gives what seems to me a clear idea of what the vision was (granted the vision has changed since then). He doesn't like DVMs either (also poison). And on and on. I don't even know all the things that make up the current mix of *all of the things*. But all this stuff is alien. Nostr has become an insanely complex web of alien civilisations. Not a bad thing, just it isn't Nostr anymore. It's a websocket-based decentralised storage and API alternative. Which, cool, but I'm not buying that this was the vision.