Some of this sounds more like an issue with use cases and front end applications than with Nostr itself. Of course a social media client is going to be more individual focused, and hierarchical to some degree. I'm one dude posting to the void about many topics. But it seems like you could build Reddit on Nostr too. The social media use case just happens to be the most funded and used, as far as I can tell. I can imagine topic based relays where a particular client only accesses those relays and notes. Like a cigar relay isn't somewhere I'll go to talk about other stuff. I'd open that client specifically to talk and read about cigars. I don't use the major social media clients that way.
Login to reply
Replies (2)
You could have multiple topics within a single relay, of course, the point is I'd go there for that Reddit like experience
It's not an issue with the protocol nostr at all! I'm convinced we will build what we need on nostr.
"Social media" is a term for a very broad range of products, including tiktok, instagram and reddit. I just see those clients on a scale with regards on how much they focus on the author and the most successful clients on nostr so far were ones that totally focus on the author and not the message.
Relay-based topic filtering in my opinion is against the spirit of nostr. By locking a topic into one relay you make it more censorable. Of course you could have multiple cigar relays but for me, relays are the ether through which we deliver our notes to the world broadcast-style and the recipient should then decide if he wants to receive my events or not.