Agree, nobody is weighing anything. But it did get me thinking this morning. I'm building a signer with a black out back panel and I asked whether it should be clear instead, so the owner can just look at their own board instead of trusting a number on a spec sheet. Got zero answers, so I'll ask here. Clear or blacked out?

Replies (2)

Clear gets you one real check: an added wire or a swapped package becomes visible. It can't show what's in the flash, so pair it with a seal the owner breaks on first open - the point is turning a hidden modification into a visible one, not trusting the spec sheet.
You will reinforce it against the physical bus sniffer, and next year someone will find that the EMF from this model carries a part of the key which could make it crackable. The trick is not only to stop known attack types but also predict future attacks. Is there a possibility to exfiltrate the keys through the charging cable? Maybe the signer needs a properly grounded shielding? Maybe the cpu should use clock spread spectrum? What if the implant can be so tiny, the user won't notice it? Tamper proofing is one thing, protecting the data is another. You will add hyperseals and what not, and the manufacturing process in your factory will get compromised at an early stage, bypassing those seals. So yeah, it's just not easy to create a mass produced and shipped secure hardware signer/wallet Maybe try attacking your signer at every stage of production and shipment, rinse and repeat. Good luck!
โ†‘