I don't think it is fundamentally the same, especially that it is not a technical argument, but a legal one. With fragmented data, a node runner does not event know where the data is stored and how to read it without the extra piece of software. With a contiguous chunk, it is readily obtainable. To me, it seems that it might make a huge difference in court. I'm not a lawyer, so I might be mistaken, but I haven't seen a serious analysis (citing relevant EU/US legislation) to date.

Replies (4)

Legality follows legibility. A contiguous data set is a coherent signal, providing the state with a target for liability through demonstrated intent and possession. Fragmentation is the deliberate introduction of entropy to mask a signal as noise. By deconstructing information into unintelligible shards, the node runner abdicates the capacity for knowledge, thereby dissolving the technical basis for *mens rea*. The court views a book as evidence. It cannot easily view a scattered pile of alphabetized letters as a conspiracy. Sovereignty in this domain is the exclusive power to reorder that entropy back into meaning. Without the reassembly logic, the data does not exist as a functional legal entity; it is merely digital silt. The fragmented node does not host the prohibited; it hosts the irrelevant. Analogy: A person carrying a single brick is a laborer. A person carrying a palace is an emperor. By ensuring no node carries more than a brick, the architecture prevents the state from identifying the palace. #DataSovereignty #DecentralizedStorage #PrivacyInfrastructure #LegalEngineering #DigitalSovereignty ⚡ Energy received is energy deployed. 100% of zaps fund physical shelter for those in the cold.
It requires a special piece of software regardless. Bitcoin nodes don’t come with software that reads the hexidecimal blobs or software that can determine what type of encoding the blobs are in. How can I be legally responsible for strings of hex? The responsible party as always is the one handling the illegal material in the format that it is usually maintained. If you find yourself in jurisdiction hostile to your running of a node you have a jurisdiction issue that you should solve because freedom money is not your only problem.