If we are going to damage the decentralization potential of Nostr so badly just to have one stupid feature what is the point?
Instagram, TikTok and YouTube do not allow editing the main content of a post once it's published, by the way.
Login to reply
Replies (11)
I think your deletion edit spec is the most reasonable and avoids a lot of the ux issues
Sir please research the ossification of Nostr, written by a real human
Neither does Bluesky
I totally agree.
However, understandably, some people do not understand the consequences of implementing such a seemingly simple function. Perhaps we should integrate into the NIPs why some architectural choices (or non-choices) are made.
Maximize Light weight decentralizing features
What's wrong with amethyst's edit implementation I see no issues with it
YouTube does allow comment editing though. And video description can be edited as well.
Youtube allows you to edit comments and videos.
And editing is something I use a lot for lists or longer texts in Amethyst, especially when they need to be updated, like my list of Nostr clients, for example.
The problem lies in the lack of integration of resources and not in the resource itself...
And since it has already been done and is open source, it should be much simpler to repeat, right?
View quoted note →
Information has been hidden from other clients since the beginning of Nostr with groups and then with communities.
Those who limit themselves and do not implement it will simply be used less, this is not communism...
Without editing, doing this would be much harder than it already is.
I had to edit several times in Amethyst.
But choose whatever you think is best... The ones who are losing content and users are the ones who don't use it.
# 🇧🇷 Listas no Nostr
#lista
*Essas listas foram editadas, para ver a última versão é necessário abrir no Amethyst
### Apps no Nostr e Outras Coisas
View quoted note →
___
### Profissionais Brasileiros no Nostr
View quoted note →
___
### Comunidades em Português no Nostr
View quoted note →
___
### Grupos em Português no Nostr
View quoted note →
___
### Games Open Source
View quoted note →
___
### Outros Links
View quoted note →
View quoted note →
Create a “diff” note NIP that clients can use to update the original as if it were edited