Finished listening this across a few drives so my thoughts are a bit scattered as I couldn't take notes.
After seeing countless viral clips and memes (mostly on twitter) of Saif "owning MMTers", I was stoked to listen to a civilized debate between a Bitcoiner Austrian economist vs Keynesians.
The Bitcoin Standard has been the most transformative and fascinating book I've ever read. And I have tremendous respect and adoration for Saif as the monetary enlightenment he teaches has opened my eyes in many other topics.
But maan... More than a debate, this felt like Saif unleashing his anger and hatered towards Keynesians. The viral clips were indeed him making some excellent points, but he was condescending and kept attacking his opponents. Repeatedly calling them "Central Bank funded left wing propagandists" isn't how you dismantle someone's fundamental arguments, that's just name calling.
It's sad because both his opponents agreed with Saif on a lot of the world's current problems while trying to make the discussion more civilized, but Saif kept going in with how the ability the print money robs people. After the 4th time that point was made, it would've been a much more educational and intellectually entertaining discussion if he actually debated them on foundational principles of Inflation vs Deflation. And how a deflationary world would look in practice, this was sadly also missing from The Bitcoin Standard, but he may talked about in his other books I haven't read yet.
There's so many more thoughts I'm forgetting... I still enjoyed listening to 3 economists intellectually sparring like that, don't get me wrong. And of course I think Saif was right in most of his points, but if the goal of a debate is to shift your opponent's (and the audience's) opinion, it has to be done step by step instead of repeating your main argument "central bank evil".
I hope if @Saifedean Ammous or prominent Bitcoiners debates again, they argue from a place of calm and curiosity while debunking arguments by breaking down their building blocks and assumptions. I still absolutely recommend everyone to give it a listen/watch, the content will be entertaining to say the least. Curious to hear what others thought.
John
its_john@nostrcheck.me
npub1gek9...jwe2
🇹🇷🇺🇸 • Product Designer
Be the change you want to see in the world.
It's a shame no Nostr developer ever tackles and markets a product with practical use that's needed by normies. Wouldn't it be insanely cool if this tweet was spreading a Nostr based P2P app?


It’s funny how everyone outside of it unanimously hates HR in most workplaces. I’ve experienced it first hand, and heard from many, countless stories that share how slow and often times incompetent they are. Anyone figured out why?

*sighs* Everything is fckng censored isn’t it…




