I find it interesting that people can simultaneously argue that Monero’s tail emission is absolutely necessary to maintain long-term mining security, while also arguing that it trends toward effectively zero so it doesn't matter. If it truly trends toward zero and becomes barely noticeable, then it doesn’t materially change mining incentives or network security. But if it does materially impact mining incentives, then the inflation is significant. You can't have both. You're confusing absolute numbers with percentages. Miners are paid in absolute terms (0.6 XMR per block), which provides a permanent baseline incentive to keep rigs running. Holders care about relative inflation (percentages). Because the emission is fixed but the supply grows, the dilution rate trends toward zero. A fixed block reward can easily fund security while the inflation rate simultaneously flatlines. It’s basic math. All Bitcoiner false claims come from not understanding basic finance and basic math. People assume you can develop theories over cryptocurrencies because it's a popular topic, but no, you can't w/o knowing some about math and monetary theory, which most people don't. We have LLMs now, people can easily share these "opinions" and hear precisely how they're wrong, but they prefer to just throw it out there anyways. That's the real "interesting" part.

Replies (2)

Economics and game theory is not “basic math”. Tail emission is a zero sum game. It’s still based on the assumption that fiat will always exist and that inflation is possible in a truly free market. If the market were truly free and fiat did not exist, why would holders need to pay miners for the security of the network outside of a fee based on demand ? Thats why Bitcoin's security model is superior- its based on the transition to a mature, market-driven fee environment where the value of the network justifies the cost of settlement.
I think you're confusing bitcoiners & maxis. Bitcoiner just means you're holding bitcoin and have some knowledge about it, while maximalists are bitcoin-only zealots. Many bitcoiners hold monero (or the other way around). Not everyone is engaged to a token, especially not cypherpunks. ;)