Replies (4)

So a kid asks a communist: "When you have two bicycles. Will you give one to me?" "Yes of course. We call it fair." "Ok" the kid said. "And if you have two cars? What would you do?" "Give one of them to you. Because we are equal!" "Wow." The kid replied. "So when you have two cows, you will give one to me?" "No, I won't! Are you stupid? I really have two cows!"
All low resolution positions. The idea that socialism or communism represents a single, unified ideology is historically absurd. The socialist movement is nearly two centuries old, extraordinarily diverse, pluralistic, and often deeply heterodox. Long before the Soviet Union existed, socialist thinkers were proposing radically different ways of organizing society. Take **Robert Owen**, for example, a successful British entrepreneur and one of the pioneers of the modern cooperative movement. He believed society could be transformed through education, cooperation, better working conditions, and the **voluntary** creation of alternative communities. Or **Pierre-Joseph Proudhon**, one of the founders of mutualism and anarchism, who opposed centralized state power and proposed systems of mutual credit, worker associations, and decentralized economic cooperation. Then there were **Charles Fourier**, who imagined voluntary cooperative communities; **Mikhail Bakunin** and **Peter Kropotkin**, who advocated forms of libertarian socialism; and later democratic socialists who pursued economic democracy through parliamentary institutions. These thinkers disagreed profoundly about property, markets, money, the state, and how social change should happen. Some socialists believed in revolution, others in gradual reform, and others in building alternative institutions from the ground up. **The great historical misconception is reducing this enormous intellectual tradition to Marxism-Leninism and the authoritarian regimes of the twentieth century.** Those regimes represent one particular historical trajectory, not the entirety of socialist thought. In fact, some of the strongest opponents of authoritarian socialism were socialists themselves. **Socialism didn't begin with Marx, and it certainly didn't begin with Lenin.** The socialist tradition has always contained competing visions of emancipation, including approaches based on voluntary association, cooperative ownership, mutual aid, economic democracy, and decentralization. We have AI now, you can actually learn things quickly. Otherwise aren't we just spewing propaganda?
We can simplify. As long as what mine is mine stays mine we can get along more or less no matter what you ideology dictates. However, if you or any other socialist claims rights over my stuff, I call my 2 frens Koch Smith and Wesson Heckler for help to discuss the dispute in more detail.
I don't think anyone wants what you have unless you're a billionaire or something of the sort. Socialist thought is very clear about the problem, the problem is not private property per se, the problem is absurd accumulation, not private property. Being pro tax is also not a mainstream position of the original socialist thought. What you see nowadays is a copy of a copy of copy. None of these people ever read anything socialist. They're just repeating what other people have said. Socialist and communist thought is very anarchist and state skeptic, especially in the beginning. That's the whole point of socialism. To distribute more opportunities for more people. It started by being very utopian, very industrious, civilized, etc. Marx and Lenine basically occupied this kind of socialist thought with the ideas of violent revolution, especially after the Paris Commune revolution. We can very much argue that those people don't represent the socialist movement. A lot of socialists are whats called libertarian market or voluntaryist socialist, and they simply want mutual credit or co-created money systems to create a better world, voluntarily. That was the origin of the socialist movement. It didn't start by talking about taxes, it started by offering utopian visions of the world and introducing new tools to create it. Very much like right wing libertarians do and believe so of Bitcoin for example. Right wing libertarians think they're inventing freedom from opression when early socialists were all over that 150 years ago. The very own libertarian definition or expression was created in socialist thought. There's a lot to be said about the socialist movement.
โ†‘