Thread

Zero-JS Hypermedia Browser

Relays: 5
Replies: 2
Generated: 16:58:46
I have seen sheikh assim many times conflate his personal views, which aren't based on Quran/hadith, with the fatwas he gives. This and some other fatwas of his essentially say something is haram or makruh, and then in lieu of a reasoning, just say why would you want to do it anyways. On the other hand this is the same guy who says meat in Europe and the US is halal unless proven otherwise because "christian country", without ever mentioning the different slaughtering practices. So it's not like he generally errs on the side of strictness. If anything, he usually leans on the side of permissiveness.
2025-07-31 16:27:47 from 1 relay(s) ↑ Parent 1 replies ↓
Login to reply

Replies (2)

The most lacking aspect of the Muslim space here is deep Islamic fundamental knowledge. We can ridicule these ignorant fatwas all we want, but I don't think anyone here has the ability to do Sheikh Assim's job. We need to spend time genuinely learning the ilm of hadith, fiqh and tafsir etc. We need to form decentralized institutions of study for these fields that can raise scholars that rival the oil funded Sheikhs giving fatwas for the governments that pay them. The ummah can't thrive without it.
2025-07-31 21:10:50 from 1 relay(s) ↑ Parent 2 replies ↓ Reply