I don't know how you conclude you touched a nerve but as you might have noticed I argued against your points, not you personally. No hard feelings man, I just think you are wrong, at least based on what I read. If I got you right, in your world we need an overarching framework with guidelines as to how we extend nostr. In mine we don't. We will still definitely have a lot of well-constructed explanatory docs about design, just not standardized by anyone. People still have the incentive to get contributors into projects just they don't have the bureaucratic process of NIPs, and a "guiding body of experts" that are appointed to cast judgement on how people write their software. You can create such a thing, it's just that I doubt any serious player needs that when we have each others npubs. Or maybe some people will find value in that. More power to them.

Replies (2)

Yall should organize a public cornhchat to debate this topic. I agree with both sides on specific things and am very opinionated on the topic myself, so i would be interested.